I might be in the minority but I am of the opinion that if you are grading students on something that can be easily obtained through a google search you probably shouldn't be grading them on that.
I might be in the minority but I am of the opinion that if you are grading students on something that can be easily obtained through a google search you probably shouldn't be grading them on that.
Replace the teacher with a coach in a weightlifting class. One day he wants you to lift some freeweights, but he wants you to lift them in a particular way that does not use your legs. (Let's say he's having you do "military presses".) "Nonsense!" says the modern student, who already knows that it's best to lift heavy things with their legs. "Why shouldn't I be able to use this awesome resource (my legs) that's right here at my disposal!?"
Well maybe - just maybe - the coach wants to target your deltoids. Hmmm.
Enter Professor Luis von Ahn, who wants you to do homework without using google. Perhaps that is because he doesn't want you to target and improve your research abilities. It could be that, rather, he would like you to exercise and sculpt your ability to work problems from first principles. The professor may be aware that practice makes permanent, and homework is intended to get students to strengthen specific things, and that taking the easy way out robs the student of the intended benefit.
That's how I approach being a student, and so I grant that when sensei says wax-on, paint-uh-fence, and sand-uh-flo that he's got some idea of what I should be working on. But that's an old, old attitude that exists only in a handful of Hollywood movies these days. So that's why I'm betting you're actually in the majority.
By the way, the instructor here is an awesome guy. Anybody who hasn't heard of Luis von Ahn should do themselves a favor and watch his presentation on Human Computation:
1) The early homeworks in this class were basically puzzles, where if you’ve seen the style of problem before you more or less knew the answer. The goal was to expose us to these types of problems and teach us how to think them through properly.
2) The class was taught by Luis just as he was beginning to hit mainstream media. The guy has a unique approach to problems that was absolutely inspiring. His lectures were one of the few that I actually made an effort to go to.
Edit: Now here is someone that was actually paying attention: I believe it was called Finkleberg’s 101 game, at least when I took the class. Maybe he pulled the same trick with a different problem several times. I remember thinking “this is such a googleable problem” because of the peculiar name so I actually assumed that a google search for the name would be a honeypot trap. My assumption proved correct.
PS: There are plenty of great resources at a top institution to learn, but you can only explore a tiny fraction of them.
I don't disagree, as long as the instructor is able to defend the pedagogical purpose of the limitations he demands. The OP is essentially contending that few situations warrant such limitations, and I agree with him about that.
I just had a thought over my morning coffee: I would agree that the instructor should be able to defend such choices to the head of the department. The instructor may choose to defend the choice to the student, but the instructor should only be required to defend the choice to the student if the student is also required to be able to defend why they should be allowed to be there. I fear the most precious thing we've lost in our modern society is a student's willingness to bring themselves to the process, and so if I (as an instructor) must defend why I've set boundaries on an exercise then then you (as the student) must be able to defend that you really want to learn what I have to teach.
Alas, higher education has been reduced to a transaction for a service, and "the customer is always right".
few situations warrant such limitations, and I agree with him about that.
I have the opposite view. Most of the homework that I've ever seen (as a Math & Comp Sci double major) was about the benefit of the exercise, and very rarely about strengthening research abilities. But, then, I was in school when Tim Berners-Lee was gestating the world wide web concept at CERN.
Google does simple math, so that's basically an equivalent issue.
IMO it's dumb -- in real life you have access to Google. But I mostly wanted to say I think there's clearly majority support for artificial grading conditions, since the no-calculators thing is so popular.
For similar reasons, we were also allowed to bring in any books, notes etc. to exams. If you didn't have a good understanding of the subject, they weren't helpful at all as there was no time to start figuring out things, but if knew stuff, you didn't need the books and lecture notes at all or only for reference.
Sometimes I miss those times.
If one is taking a class merely to learn how to Google for the answers, then one should not be in a university. One should be in a trade school which only teaches you enough of your fields of study to be able to figure out the right terms to Google for.
When you take university classes, the goal is to learn to be the people that provide the solutions that the trade schoolers will Google for.
There are only so many simple recursive procedures, and I guarantee nearly all of them are online.
That said, I do think that once students have a basic understanding of computer science all assignments should be given so that the answer are not online. And this wouldn't bee to hard, even. It would just take some effort by the professor.
(lazy student speaking from personal experience. being graded on the homework 'encouraged' learning the concepts!)
And that is bad, why exactly? You're unprepared, you fail, you learn a lesson, you retake. Repeat until done. I too was a lazy student and found that failing a few classes and having to resit the exam was a fine way to motivate you to study.
For example have them write a program that solves the game of Nim, but don't tell them the name of the game they are solving. Instead call it "pick up pennies" or something like that. Now Google won't help.
However, there will be someone in the class who knows that "pick up pennies" is just the game of Nim, and will google it. Renaming makes it harder so fewer people will be able to cheat, but it doesn't make it impossible. (That said, it wouldn't be all that hard for the professor to create his own game which is similar to Nim in some respects, but different in others -- I believe this would be the best solution -- but unfortunately most professors would not put the time in to do this.)
This problem multiplies tenfold when you try to do it with math. (Integrate _____ -> WolframAlpha. Prove ______ -> Google.)
In general, creating good, well-balanced problems isn't easy! And many of the "classic" examples are classic precisely because they incorporate just the right blend of concepts in an unusually simple package. That's not easy to duplicate, if it's possible at all. (I do my best to write exam problems that way, but it can be a tortuous process.)
This is a situation where you can't give problems to an undergraduate student that are easy enough to answer while they're simultaneously impossible to Google. I'd love to give my own students the opportunity to experience these types of critical thinking questions. Unfortunately, I know that I'm completely incapable of assigning ungoogleable problems without turning them into some Dr. House shit that can't be answered by a college student.
Few people would say it's wrong to not be able to google during an exam, but most would agree that not googling during exercises is insane.
Just to take a trivial example: take a look at Project Euler. There's no question in my mind that working through those exercises is a valuable learning experience, and (in the context of a programming course) would be worth grading someone on-- even though the answers are readily available to anyone who searches for them.
How in the world you got that out of my comment is beyond me.
People cheat with resources available it is a sad fact but it is true. You are being unfair if you decide to punish honest students by grading on something that is easily available (I've seen homework grades as 30% off class grades before).