I remember that malware was rampant on Windows back in the 90’s and early 00’s.
And some of that malware probably did collect information on you.
Either way, the point I am trying to make is that desktop software is not as benign as you are making it out to be.
And even some of the desktop operating systems have been doing telemetry or advertising related things in the OS itself.
Ubuntu. https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/ubuntu-spyware.en.html
Windows 7 and 8.1 telemetry. https://mspoweruser.com/microsoft-makes-telemetry-updates-fo...
Windows 10 built-in advertising. https://www.howtogeek.com/269331/how-to-disable-all-of-windo...
I don’t get why or how people put up with this bullshit.
When did this happen? Obviously it was a gradual change, but when about was the inflection point? I'd estimate sometime around 2007.
The data Malware and spyware went after was your credit card number, and bank account & passwords. Which they then used to steal money from you.
No one ever was worried that malware would build a profile of them and sell it to internet advertisers who would send them more relevant ads.
I can download a random desktop application from the internet onto my Windows machine and, without notifying me, gaining root, or getting my permission, it can access my connected camera and microphone, access my personal documents anywhere in the file system my user has access to, access the network, list all the other network connections I currently have open, activate my printer, read my address book, and list all the software I have on my computer. And if I don’t affirmatively deny it by setting up an outbound firewall, that desktop software can send that information anywhere it likes.
Mobile has not solved all these consent problems but is farther along.
It sounds to me, and other commenters, that you simply are misremembering the past and ignoring current trends that have nothing to do with electron.
Not to mention the fact that Electron apps just bundle an archive containing the app sources (minified or not), whereas you’re not necessarily going to be able to read the source code of a C++ app running on your system.
Native applications, that is, applications, have a long history of being able to do things without constant connections to the internet or any connection at all.