If We Blow Up an Asteroid, It Might Put Itself Back Together
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
You're right that gravity tractors aren't easy. Nothing is easy in space.
Also, there’s beam divergence (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beam_divergence). That has a theoretical lower limit (http://www.aml.engineering.columbia.edu/ntm/level1/ch02/html...). Reading https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/1ihca9/how_much..., that limit is about 1:3000, so a laser beam is at least 100 km wide at the earth-moon distance.
I guess you would want to start rotating that asteroid way earlier, and that you would want to hit asteroids smaller than that. That makes it practically infeasible (Given infinitely precise aim, you theoretically still would be able to hit it only at one side, by aiming off-target, but that would wasting most of your beam energy)
Also, I am not convinced evaporating the surface by heating it from an angle would significantly impart angular momentum.
Always surprised how little science there is in this stuff, both detection and diversion it is a real existential threat to humanity given enough time and yet militaries around the world are out there tilting at windmills spending all their cash on outdated bloated acquisition projects to kill each other better in the most peaceful time on Earth.
I tried to figure out just how accurately we are able to point stuff in space and found out the hubble telescope is able to "lock onto a target without deviating more than 7/1000th of an arcsecond, or about the width of a human hair seen at a distance of 1 mile." [1]
That's pretty amazing to me. Though I'm not sure if that would be enough, or whether we can be even more accurate.
With a laser beam it might also not be a problem if you're just slightly inaccurate, say only hitting your mark 70% of the time as long as you still manage to heat your target spot up sufficiently.
[1]: https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/hubble/story/index.html
Since people smarter than me have floated this as a way of deflecting asteroids, I assume there's some kind of way to focus it over those distances? It seems nontrivial though.
Maybe if we had 20 year's notice, we might be able to do something. But even then, probably not.
The biggest known potentially hazardous asteroid is only 7 km in diameter. (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/(53319)_1999_JM8).
> The study has limitations. Both asteroids are modeled as simple, nonrotating chunks of rock, whereas real asteroids are far more variable. In addition, the larger asteroid, despite featuring a starting collection of cracks, did not have a history of multiple impacts as true asteroids would.
Sounds like this model was designed to generate sensationalized headlines like this one.
My guess is that without rotation, the tidal forces of the other bodies that are far away are small enough to be ignored. In a perfectly even gravitational field, all the parts of the comment has the same acceleration from the other bodies and it can be canceled. (Like the "zero gravity" effect in the ISS.) So only the forces between the fragments of the asteroid are relevant.
Anyway, the Shoemaker–Levy 9 comet suffered some disruption due to gravitational tidal forces because it passed too close to Jupiter, and the fragments formed a line instead of a ball. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comet_Shoemaker–Levy_9