How Anna Delvey Tricked New York’s Party People (2018)
thecut.com
thecut.com
Tom Draper will go on record saying he'd invest in Holmes, a known scammer, again. Why?
Draper's behavior makes sense if he still sees Holmes as Holmes sees herself, as a visionary who had to make some ethical concessions for the sake of a dream. I think both of them still believe that the machines would have worked eventually, and they had to keep the hype wave going or else everything would collapse. I bet both of them could imagine a universe where the machines did end up working and their indiscretions were relegated to footnotes in gossipy Tell-Alls written 20 years from now.
(Isn't there some story about Bill Gates promising software he didn't yet possess in order to close a key deal? Imagine if that didn't work out as well as it did...)
Similarly, while the article paints Delvey as a scammer who just won't admit to it, I think it's possible that Delvey never saw her actions as "scamming"... Her attitude was probably a mix of egomania and extreme narcissism, something like: "banks have so much money anyway, and I was going to use it better than anyone else could."
In fact, she straight-up says this at the end of the piece:
> “Money, like, there’s an unlimited amount of capital in the world, you know?” Anna said to me at one point. “But there’s limited amounts of people who are talented.”
I could be misreading this, but based on the previous paragraph, it seems like the author is implying that Delvey is talking about how she's so talented at deceiving people. But I don't think that's what Delvey means at all. I think she sincerely believes she's deeply and profoundly talented in a positive sense, and therefore money and power should be hers (because in a just universe, money & power accrue to the talented), and if she has to cut some corners to acquire this money and power that is rightfully hers, so be it. Same mindset as Holmes.
"Fake it until you make it" can be useful in certain circumstances, but this ideology is dangerous in the hands of delusional people who are convinced that they're brilliant.
I can even kind of see that, from a VC's perspective, this trait may be even more important to them than the intelligence and skill. Their business is built around investing in 20 crazy-ambitious ideas with the expectation that 19 will fail, but the other one will go big enough to pay off the loss of the other 19 and still provide huge gains. Better then to stick with the delusionally optimistic rather than reasonable and sane business plans that will probably make decent money but will never grow 1000x.
You still need to add mendacity.
If Musk, Gates etc. had been less lucky, would they have turned to lie to try and manufacture luck? They probably did a little bit -- would they do it at a criminal level?
Some might have; it's a thing that some people do. But it is unfair on them to assume that they would have.
I think if you want to play the "what's more interesting" game, it isn't that Theranos was particularly notable. Scams happen all the time, and at the end of the day the crime was to have taken $700M in investments based on a lie. I mean, that's, like, really bad. But be real: we're hardly talking Enron or Madoff here.
But some folks just Won't Let Theranos Go. It comes up again and again and again as some kind of existential moral statement instead of the one-every-few-years business scandal that it actually is. And as far as I can tell, the only reason for this is that some of the early investors (that's right, the victims of the crime) were Democrats.
In seriousness, I know in some narrow and uninteresting sense you regard your point of view as accurate. But surely the fact that so many supposedly smart people were duped is what made these stories newsworthy.
* You mean every AI/Hardware/Cloud start-up isn't a magic factory of philanthropy/social justice/innovation??
* You mean investors/rich-people make MISTAKES?? But they PAY people to do due-diligence right?
* You mean coming from a wealthy, well-connected, family, gives you an egregious head start in the diverse and democratizing tech world??
* You mean a Woman can lie, cheat, and steal, just like a Man?
What? No... it's because we'd never seen the Silicon Valley Startup Hype Machine ramped up to it's fully glory before like Theranos. Also svelte young blueeyed blondes are catnip to media, combine that with "youngest self made female billionaire" and it's mandatory reporting and guaranteed spotlight in the public eye... throwing the fact that it was all a scam and renewed interest and modern popularity with TrueCrime genre and modern scammers like Anna Delvey and Fyre Festival and .... kaboom, here we are. Didn't hurt that Bad Blood was also excellently written and well-researched. All in all an excellent story.
Yes, actually, it was.
The primary issue is that Silicon Valley runs on "Fake It Until You Make It" very strongly. That's not a real big deal when you are delivering dog food or hooking up hipsters for sex--the money simply goes down the drain and that's life.
Once you start the path toward something that has real consequence--diagnosing medical issues or piloting a 2 ton death machine without a human--you've jumped a VERY important line. "Fake It Until You Make It" isn't good enough--engineering now matters and people can get badly hurt. The standard goes up and you had better pay attention.
The secondary issue was the nature of Holmes privilege. She had no qualifications to do what she was doing and still managed to pull in a whopping amount of funding from very connected people without oversight--not necessarily an issue in and unto itself. However, when things were going badly, she didn't fess up--she pressed forward by lying about it and then intimidated (possibly criminally) those who attempted to expose it. That's crossing the line.
And, to be fair, I find the "scientists" who were Theranos' mouthpieces through this to be far more guilty and wish their names were being promulgated much more strongly so that they can suffer the appropriate censure for aiding and abetting her.
It's easy to look from the outside in and question how these people could fall for these types of frauds, but I think most people are more susceptible to them than they realize.
Really, what cons are about is selling people a version of the future that they want. With Delvey, her associates were probably motivated to believe her because she spent money freely, and she seemed to belong to a "higher" social order.
What Holmes was selling wasn't blood testing kits, she was selling the idea that healthcare could be "disrupted" and progress the same way that software could. I'm not exactly sure who Tom Draper is or what he said, but for wealthy older people, who may have significant financial stakes in Theranos, you can see why this would be an attractive reality. In contrast, the alternate reality -- that you got suckered in by a fraudster and the progression of healthcare will be as slow and bureaucratic as ever (which means the quality of your life over the next 30 years will slowly, then quickly, decline probably past the point where you will logically want to live anymore)-- seems far less appealing.
It reminds me of someone who I worked with who was a Libertarian. He used to go around trying to "convert" people, and the only things he would ask was "Wouldn't you like to pay less money in taxes? If you didn't have to pay taxes what would you buy? Can you imagine how much money you would make if you didn't have to pay taxes?". He managed to convince like 90% of people that way.
Every hotel I stayed at makes me prepay and put a deposit down for incidentals. It seems the hotels mentioned in the article failed to do even basic diligence and even violated their own rules by allowing Anna to stay at a hotel without a valid credit card or deposit. That is their incompetence and shouldn't involve the criminal system.
Edit: This is also why faking loan documents and wire fraud is a crime.
It doesn't suddenly become non-criminal to defraud someone just because they didn't insist on the money in advance. She obtained services under the pretense she'd be able to pay for it, and didn't pay. That's basically the definition of "theft of services", and only in scale different from you jumping out of a cab at the end of the journey and running away without paying.
I don't think anybody would like it if, say, every hotel in the country wouldn't give you a room without the full cost prepaid in a confirmed bank transfer ahead of time, plus enough of a deposit to cover any mess you might make. Particularly the actual high-roller customers that they really want. And so people generally get a certain amount of trust extended to them, generally with various bad consequences for violating that trust.
Not a lawyer, but I think you can technically be charged criminally for most such thefts. It's just not commonly done for single acts and small amounts, because the process is expensive for everyone, and more modest measures are usually good enough for everyone involved. But when you run around like Anna did, constantly juggling bank accounts and credit cards and making promises all over the city but never actually paying anyone, and keep it going for months and months and do it to like a half dozen hotels, eventually, there needs to be some firmer consequences than just trying to get money out of a stone.
https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2018/04/my-misadventure-with...
In this case the “make it” part is yet to happen.
I’m pointing out an eerie similarity between the protagonist’s behaviour and Silicon Valley business ethics.