Myhrvold's Intellectual Ventures arms HTC with big patent trove
techflash.com
techflash.com
However, for non-trivial things, there's nothing wrong with Myhrvold's approach. For those things IV itself develops, the patent system is doing just what it was intended to do--they put money into development, with the intent of using patent licensing fees to get that investment back and make a profit. Hence, it encourages the progress of the useful arts.
Same goes for patents they buy. There are many people who are able to invent something, and do the R&D to show that it will work, but do not have the skill or resources to set up manufacturing. In this case, what IV provides is a market that allows people who can invent but can't set up manufacturing to connect with those who can set up manufacturing but need inventions to manufacture.
Neither HTC nor Intellectual Ventures are acting in the same spirit.
The patent system was conceived to allow the little guy (or little business) to invent, and profit from those inventions, even when he lacked the means or scale of manufacture to reliably profit from that invention.
Without such protection obviously there was no way that someone who invented a new method to harness energy from gasoline, for instance, could avoid getting crushed by an established car company: He would have close to zero leverage in such a transaction, and there was little to prevent them from simply saying "thanks".
Honestly I suspect that if companies above some threshold were barred from filing patents, it would have no impact at all on their R&D spend. It might even improve efficiencies as they stop focusing on trying to land grab with hundreds of trivial patents (which is sadly what most patents are now, where offenders accidentally offend simply in the course of building things because overlap is unavoidable).
There is nothing, whatsoever, morally different between patent trolls and a company like Apple. They are both playing the same game to enrich themselves at the cost of everyone else. As the old saying goes, however, don't hate the players, hate the game, so kudos to Apple for doing what they can to ensure that $4 billion + of profit enriches their account every quarter.
But when you say that my argument is "absurdity that borders on embarrassing," you take an otherwise interesting discussion and ruin it with ad hominems. I can't find the strength to get into anything further on the topic.
Good day to you, sir.
Though the image of you putting on your top hat and adjusting your monocle was delightful. I pray that you haven't succumbed to the vapors.
Patents (which trace back to Venice circa 1474) were always were protections for individual inventors and creators. The "everyone churn out patents for the company to lay a monster landclaim --- just take what you find and add "with a computer" or "with a touchscreen" and we're golden", with patent ownership reverting to the corporate entity, is an altogether recent concept.
I would appreciate a source if I am wrong.
Virtually all invention was a individual or small group pursuit.