2,891 Murdoch Media Stories Trashing Islam in a Single Year, Study Reveals
newmatilda.com
newmatilda.com
It's also important to highlight the article's last two paragraphs as it constrasts significantly with the tone of the headline:
> Articles were regarded as “negative articles written about Islam”, if they “referred to Islam or Muslims alongside words like violence, extremism, terrorism or radical”. It should be noted – this is a pretty expansive definition. A story that accurately reported a noteworthy incident of Muslim violence, without being inflammatory or misrepresenting material facts, and which had the respectful cooperation of Muslims, would still be caught up under this definition.
> Indeed, the definition could go further. A report that noted Muslim women in a non-government organisation helping victims of domestic violence might also be caught up under this definition. It should also be noted – there is an implicit slippage, in the sense that a negative story about Muslims isn’t necessarily a story about Islam. Thus, I would argue that the definition may be overbroad.
Edit: Originally, I erroneously wrote that this was 8 per day across all Murdoch owned outlets. That is not the case, it is among 5 specific ones.
Edit: Would you say it's 8 too many per day if they were trashing Trump? (or Israel, or Hillary Clinton, or anything/anybody else with faults)
Let's be clear: there absolutely are valid reasons to be critical of Islam. It is entirely appropriate, for example, to "trash" the fact that in some regions of the word the majority of Muslims support executing those that leave the religion: http://www.pewforum.org/2013/04/30/the-worlds-muslims-religi...
The undertone of the article seems to be implying that negative media coverage of Islam is reponsible for Islamaphobia. While I'm sure many people erroneous apply negative comments about trends in Islam asa whole with individual Muslims, the blanket assumption that criticism of Islam equates to Islamaphobia is also reductive and non-productive.
(Deleted bit about the number of companies Murdoch owns, as it is not relevant to the study in question).
Incidentally, I would be interested in the amount of negative coverage, say, the Catholic Church gets in the media as a point of comparison, perhaps especially in the left-leaning media.
Note the focus of some of these articles on individual incidents in a civil war, for example a particular group of predominantly Muslims killing a lot of Christians on a particular day. The reporter neglects to cover the other six days of the week when many more Muslims were killed by this group.
Is that fair coverage? Does it appear to be accurate? Is it negative about Islam?
Real people are suffering and dying today at the hands of those with a more fundamentalist interpretation of Islam.
By suggesting Islam should not be criticised, you are an apologist for that oppression.
No. Five newspapers.
"The report investigates how five newspapers covered Islam in 2017... The newspapers were all Murdoch’s: the Australian, Herald Sun, Daily Telegraph, Courier Mail, and Adelaide Advertiser."
There are presumably many thousands more in the other Murdoch properties around the world.
> The report investigates how five newspapers covered Islam in 2017
This was around the time of peak ISIS and peak Syrian civil war, the prefect time to be seeing those terms thrown around. Did they break down what section they appeared in too? 8 a day in the first couple of pages seems excessive, but if they include 3 line articles in the world news section then it's more than reasonable.
Andrew Bolt though, no matter what your view on Islam, does it really deserve mentioning in 38% of his articles.
Depends on what is his work area and interests. Journalists often work in specific segments. If somebody covers US White House, it'd be no wonder they mention Trump frequently. If somebody covers British politics, there would be tons of Brexit. If somebody covers Middle East and Syria, well, there would be a lot of ISIS and such. And if somebody is into crypto currencies, there would be a lot of Bitcoin mentions. I don't think its more fair to say it's obsession than saying a particular sports journalist is "obsessed with baseball" because 38% of his articles mention the sport. Yet less it means the particular person hates baseball and is "baseballphobic".
> And if somebody is into crypto currencies, there would be a lot of Bitcoin mentions.
And that would show a clear bias, which I think is also demonstrated for Bolt.
A much more reputable study with actual controls: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/jul/20/muslim-terro...
So, they're not separating factual reporting from fake news about islam? How does this not entirely invalidate the study?
Yes, islam gets discussed a lot... but islamist extremism is a global problem. Calling criticism of islam "islamophobia" is incredibly counterproductive. The more we try to clamp down on criticism of islam, the more we stoke anti-islamist fears and hatreds.
This pisses me off as much as seeing people still defending convicted pedophiles like George Pell because they're catholic clergy.
I get that people like their religions. That doesn't mean those religions should be placed above reproach. We need to make a clear distinction between criticism of islam and islamophobia. As far as I can see (since I refuse to disable my anti-tracking and anti-ad plugins on a strange site) the study the article is talking about doesn't do that.
One important question is how many of these stories are substancially true?
It is one thing to call for the suppression of false stories. It is another thing entirely to call for the suppression of true stories.
Does this, then, mean that true stories are automatically OK? Not necessarily; Weak men are Superweapons: https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/05/12/weak-men-are-superweap...
The system has an incentive to never produce a victor, only to prolong the conflict.
Much fighting in these wars occurs in social and traditional media, centered around "battleground topics", the OP being a clear example.
The OP is an example of a message in the battleground topic of "Islam vs the West" (aside: which is actually historically incorrect since Islam really can be said to be closer to the West than separate from it, one reason is that Islam revived Europe / Western civilization around the Mediterranean 1000 years ago [1]).
The OP article supports for the Islam side, one of many such articles. There are also many articles supporting the West side of this battleground topic.
The system will not permit there to be a conclusion to the argument, it is actually motivated to promote both sides, because this constant state of conflict is stabilizing to the democratic systems.
[1]: read this book, https://www.amazon.com/Why-West-Rules-Now-Patterns/dp/031261...
I assume I know the same facts as you, and I choose a different interpretation. But maybe that's not true, maybe the facts you and I know are different.
If you read the entire book, I think you'll know why I say Islam is part of the West, not versus it.
A quick internet search tells me there are about 1.5 billion Muslims in the world and about 2.19 billion Christians.
If we consider the amount of media attention the various catholic churches have been receiving it isn't difficult to believe the number of "negative" stories could be much higher than ~3000 per year.
Does anyone know if this comparison has been done?
> It’s a shame that the study didn’t investigate other media more fully. .... Interestingly, though Fairfax has considerably less coverage of Muslims than the Murdoch press, it’s still pretty substantial, at over 100 every month. That is, over three negative stories every day at the less Islam-obsessed Fairfax. ...
I hate this kind of "study". It is impossible to put them in context.
- Are those media generally negative toward everything, or just Islam?
- How many Islam stories do they publish?
- How many positive Islam stories do they publish?
- How many are objective facts? How many are commentary?
- How does this number compare to, let's say, Christian / Scientology / science etc?
This post questions his title and Wikipedia states he's a self proclaimed Imam. His website seems to reference some authorities claiming hes legit: https://imamtawhidi.com/licenses/
He's far from perfect in all of his messaging but overall his messages are positive.