But yeah coal is a huge problem (and the "clean" coal fallacy must die asap).
Huh. Well I stand corrected:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Oil-fired_power_statio...
But I also read elsewhere they only make up 8 percent of the total in the USA and are being phased out.
A fraction of a percent now.
http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/epm/table1_1.html
It's not a sane choice; burning oil for electricity is absurdly expensive.
According to the EPA, it was 20% of NYC's electricity as of 2005:
http://www.epa.gov/cleanenergy/energy-and-you/how-clean.html
"You’ve shown that electric cars are more energy-efficient than fossil cars. But are they better if our objective is to reduce CO2 emissions, and the electricity is still generated by fossil power-stations?
This is quite an easy calculation to do. Assume the electric vehicle’s energy cost is 20 kWh(e) per 100 km. (I think 15 kWh(e) per 100 km is perfectly possible, but let’s play sceptical in this calculation.) If grid electricity has a carbon footprint of 500 g per kWh(e) then the effective emissions of this vehicle are 100 g CO2 per km, which is as good as the best fossil cars (figure 20.9). So I conclude that switching to electric cars is already a good idea, even before we green our electricity supply."
and
"I’ve looked up the performance figures for lots of electric vehicles – they’re listed in this chapter’s end-notes – and they seem to be consistent with this summary: electric vehicles can deliver transport at an energy cost of roughly 15 kWh per 100 km. That’s five times better than our baseline fossil-car, and significantly better than any hybrid cars. Hurray!"
[1] Full text available online. That's why I am not giving page numbers, just use a search engine.
I'm surprised MacKay said this, as it's misleading to compare heat energy (the heat content of a liquid fuel) with electric. That "five times better" figure basically comes from shifting the combustion of fossil fuel (and its thermodynamic losses) from the car to the power plant -- it's an artifact of the definition.
In fact, based on the EPA's Chevy Volt numbers (which may or may not be representative), it could be more efficient to burn gas in the Volt, than fossil fuel in a power plant for its electric engine. How I figure:
37 mpg on gas means 2.70 gallons/100 miles = 348 megajoules/100 miles (energy density of gasoline is 34 MJ/L [1])
On the electric side, it uses 36 kWh (130 MJ) electricity/100 miles. According to EIA figures, average US power plant efficiencies are [2]:
* for oil, 31% efficiency --> Volt uses 418 MJ power plant oil/100 miles
* for coal, 33% efficiency --> Volt uses 394 MJ power plant coal/100 miles
* for natural gas, 41% efficiency --> Volt uses 315 MJ power plant NG/100 miles
The CO2 emissions on electric are lower in the Volt, not because of an efficiency advantage, but because some of the electricity sources (hydro, nuclear) aren't fossil fuels. Likewise, the cost/mile is usually lower because the per-Joule cost of coal and natural gas are far lower than that of oil and gasoline.
Yes, that may be a bit surprising, considering that he's very explicit about that topic in the chapter on heating houses. There he mentions that you can get >100% efficiency by burning gas to make electricity in the power plants, and then driving heat pumps in your home.
Electric cars need larger scale infrastructure changes beyond simply changing the cars or providing charging infrastructure but everyone always knew that.
You just spent $41,000 on a Volt. Let's assume you drive this thing to the very limit of its electric-only range pretty much every work day, or 35 miles (advertised). You'd spend about $225 on electricity over the course of the year to get around like this.
Your neighbor just bought a bottom-of-the-line Ford Fusion (non-hybrid, 22 MPG city) for a notch under $20k. Driving the same 35 miles every work day, they'll burn 1.6 gallons of fuel daily and where I'm from that translates to an annual fuel cost of $1,080, or $855 more per year than you.
It would take you 24 years (210,000 miles) at that kind of fuel cost advantage to offset the price you paid for the car.
You're not saving money. You're not saving the environment.
And aren’t electric cars all about large scale infrastructure change anyway, not individuals curbing CO2 emissions? Say we find a way to satisfy our electric energy needs mostly without producing any CO2 within the next, say, thirty years. If our streets at that point are still full with gasoline cars we will be unable to reduce their CO2 emissions quickly. We consequently need to change the cars we are driving. As far as I know all proposed ways of doing that – whether hydrogen or electric – require large scale infrastructure changes and development of the right technology. Things like that take time.
If we don’t want to have only gasoline cars on the streets I guess we should start rolling out the first alternatives, well, probably right about now.
There's noting wrong with wanting a car because it looks cool, because it has some hot new piece of tech, or because the amount of dollars you spend on your car somehow makes you feel better about yourself. And to those people, fuel economy makes little difference.
Reducing dependence on foreign oil?
It gives you options about power source and an electric motor in itself is much more efficient than a mechanical "explosion" based motor.
We're just not quite there yet on a good, cheap, source of power. Unfortunately cannot plug in to a solar array for a week or two!
People pay a lot of money for higher esteem vehicles. It funds most hybrids (which by themselves are seldom a net return).