It should not be a percentage, it should be a fixed rate. A few thousand dollars. Or hourly.
Until people can set different rates, or you have the option of fixed rates if that is the preference of agent & buyer it won't be honest.
It should not be a percentage, it should be a fixed rate. A few thousand dollars. Or hourly.
Until people can set different rates, or you have the option of fixed rates if that is the preference of agent & buyer it won't be honest.
People gotta remember, the commission is split 4 ways unless one of the agents is a broker. Most agents themselves are only getting 1.5%
People CAN set different rates. Redfin charges a very low percentage compared to others. There are brokerages who charge flat fees, and will just slap your house in the MLS and then call it a day. You wanna list with a discount broker go for it... You can even sell your house yourself!
This whole thread reads like a bunch of people talking about tech people. "Oh you just sit at your computer all day surfing the web, why do you make so much?" or "Why pay you so much, I can just set up a website on Wix for $10."
Yeah there's some shady shit with the NAR and access to listing services, I'm not disagreeing with it 100%, but the average agent is doing a lot more work than you realize.
Allow me to introduce you to a place called California. In Santa Monica, where I live, median home price is over $1.5M. Yes, median. La Jolla is about the same. Irvine is just shy of $1M. In San Francisco it's over $1.2M median. San Jose is right around $1M. Mountain View is north of $1.7M. Etc. These places represent thousands of homes and average time on market is generally around a month. It's really that insane.
I mean, that's a valid point in the age of Wix and Squarespace. I'm certainly glad I'm no longer in the business of building brochureware sites for small clients.
I understand your larger point that we shouldn't be quick to assume a realtor's work is not difficult. However, I think the issue is the buyer doesn't really have the option to forego the buyer's agent service and capture (through a reduced price) the commission that would have otherwise been paid. Not everyone needs a full-service realtor in the same way not everyone needs a bespoke CMS.
Do they? I had a realtor once who worked for 2%. Anecdotally, it didn't seem like she was being run out of town. In retrospect, I'd rather have paid 3% for a realtor who did a better job. That extra percent was not worth the months the property sat unsold.
So why does anyone use them? Other people must think they bring more value than they cost. And if they're too expensive why aren't people undercutting?
As the article points out, the realtor cartel works to de-platform individual realtors who undercut the fee by shutting them out of associations (broker networks) and in some cases removing local MLS access. By law, you have to be a licensed realtor to broker real estate sales.
They do not have to be a Realtor to broker real estate sales. They need to be licensed real estate brokers. Being a Realtor is optional.
Source: am a non practicing licensed sales person in my home state. I can't do anything without a broker supervising me. Also I am no longer a Realtor, I was when I was an agent for a broker who was and required NAR membership.
Also, it may be different where you are, but 25% is the standard for referrals (from the buyer or seller side).
To me, it seems easier to generate quality leads, and then refer them to a buyer agent.