I wouldn't say it never goes as smoothly as they describe, at least in my experience. My experience with the iphone xs + airpods is about:
50% as they describe
49% have to go through bluetooth menu for instant pair
1% they never connect, extreme frustration, have to completely re-pair (no different than any other bluetooth product here, just don't experience it as often with airpods).
With Macbook I almost always have to go into bluetooth. There is no switching experience as they originally showed in the airpods keynote. They actually ended up rescinding the statement that they would do this after the keynote, which is super disappointing.