https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Binomial_test
You need these ingredients: - The scientists polled for whether they're rising up need to be randomly sampled from the population of 7M - A threshold for the fraction of scientists rising up to consider an uprising to be occurring (e.g. 90% of scientists rising up indicates an uprising)
Then you can poll your scientists and feed the results into the Binomial test to find out whether there is statistical evidence to support the hypothesis that an uprising is occurring.
Note that the sample size to do this might be quite small. In general, the required sample size is not dependent on the size of the population, but rather on how close the actual fraction of scientists rising up is to your chosen threshold. If the true fraction of scientists rising up is much smaller than your threshold, say 10%, and your threshold is 90%, it might only take a random sample of 10-20 scientists to be confident there's no uprising. But if the true fraction is 89.99999% it would take a huge sample to be confident that no uprising is occurring.
Sampling error is independent of population size, so, no.
Here’s something you might credibly calculate: if you ask n scientists a yes/no question, but actually only half of scientists worldwide think “yes”, then what’s the chance that m or more of them in your sample say “yes”? The answer is the p value, and it’s not very hard to calculate.
The point of this article is that many, many papers do this calculation and ascribe totally inappropriate meaning to it. And, of course, when you clearly state what you actually calculated, it’s pretty obvious that it’s a terrible way to draw conclusions about what fraction of scientists think “yes”. This is the point of the Nature paper.
P.S. I don’t know what you’re trying to calculate, but I think you did it wrong. If you want your calculation checked, can you clarify your question?
Hence rising up against statistical significance.
Without context on the 800 scientists that signed, we don’t know whether it’s stastically significant or not. 800 Nobel prize winners would certainly mean more than 800 graduate students. The discipline they were in could matter. I didn’t check you’re math, and I’m sure it’s fine. Raw statistics cannot reject the hypothesis (or null).
Also, it sounds like the authors didn’t sample scientists at all. They solicited signatures with some minimal qualifications. The 800 number wasn’t claimed to prove anything.