I think we are just all over thinking this stuff. The purpose of the web is to share things with other people.
How does that in any way remove the need for a sound legal framework defining the limits of IP rights for this use case? Do you think everything put on the web should be considered public domain?
In my personal opinion -- Emphatic yes. Copyright law is tyrannical and should be abolished.
If you don't want to serve the content then don't serve the content.