When Google was 10x the size of Facebook and preparing to launch Google+ the battle cry of "Carthage must be destroyed" was empowering against something that seemed like an existential threat to the company. Take it out of that time and place and its aggressive and creepy.
How many companies would make historical all-company emails accessible and searchable by future staff? Doing so means that companies now need to treat absolutely every internal email as potentially public and run it through an PR filter. That's a huge cost for a company that wants to move fast.