No, it's not. There are always counterexamples, but in your argument you completely ignore margins in the PC and laptop market. The vast majority of laptop and PCs are sold at low margins. Since most manufacturers cannot compete one software, they compete on price. One of the few vendors that makes large margins has its own operating system. Of course, Macs are nice hardware-wise, but most people will switch 'because it is not Windows'.
This doesn't mean that every company differentiating on software-succeeds.
ignore that the top selling devices are high-end devices like the Droid X, Galaxy S, Desire Z, etc
The smartphone market is relatively small and new, as is Android. The race to the bottom has just started.