> tax the appreciation of assets owned by the very wealthy as income each year, an approach known as mark-to-market taxation
> the proposal would be structured to affect only the richest 0.1 percent of Americans
Yeah, it's almost certainly a terrible idea.
(1) Mark-to-market is terrible, unrealistic, and arbitrary. Imagine a 70 year old grandma owning a house in SF... it's price rises 20% in a year, what is she to do? She has no money... the only thing she can do is sell the house! Even worse, what happens when there's a crisis, and house prices fall 20%? You lost more than you gained, and you still owe last year's tax!
(2) only top 0.1% and like ordinary income is fundamentally incompatible - I agree that capital gains should be taxed like income (and with the tax / offshore assets reforms that the US has done in the past few years, it's uniquely positioned among countries to actually implement such tax), but I see no reason why it shouldn't apply to everybody (same as income tax).