I also object to your notions of "gifted, talented young people". People are not collections of talents waiting to be mined; they are the product of specific cultural and social histories. I went to the best schools in the world because my parents had a specific class history, were funneled into a particular segment of American society, and made basic choices committing me to an educational course in line with the expectations and norms of their class. You might call that "talent" - but I didn't learn number theory at 14 merely because I was talented, I learned it because (1) someone else had already invented number theory and (2) I had access to people who had learned the same because of my social history.
There is wealth inequality and then there is wealth inequality. There is a difference between a society in which the average employer earns 30 times more than the average employee, and a society in which the average employer earns 300 times more than the average employee, or one in which the average employer earns 3000 times more than the average employee. Repeat those statements with median.
There is also a huge difference between a society with a Gini index of 0.28 and one with a Gini index of 0.49. And it makes a huge difference if the index is increasing or decreasing or staying stable.
There are dozens of other factors and indicators that can and should be taken into account. For example, the percentage of income spent on rent is a huge factor. If you spend more and more income on rent, your discretionary salary disappears very fast.
You seem to assume that any kind of wealth and resource distribution is fine, as long as society is just meritocratic, but that's clearly not the case.
Moreover, this cannot just about chances for the talented. You also want to live in a society in which untalented people can live a decent life in dignity, a society in which relative poverty does not lead to widespread social unrest or crime.
If the gap between rich and poor wouldn't continually increase and the trend wasn't further aggravated by existing inheritance laws, there would not even be a need for discussion.
In any case, I think those things are wealth, and if they were massively larger and involved lots more people then that would be more wealth equality.
The people who decide whether the outcome of the present system is or is not sufficiently worse than they would expect in a revolution in which they dispossess those visibly advantaged by the present system by force to justify engaging in such a revolution, ultimately, decide; at least, that is clearly the author’s point, and as a billionaire he has a vested interest in that decision not coming up in favor of revolution.
> And what happens when it is "not acceptable"?
Blood in the streets is what happens, or at least the inmediate, direct, personal threat of it.
That's kind of what Dalio (and all of the other people seeking mitigation of the same trends within the system) is (and are) doing.
I would add paid leave and reduced work hours to my above perks, as I think it’s beneficial for people to be able to participate in civic life, which requires time and for their own leisure.
But, when you start talking 100,000:1 are they actually that productive or is something else going on.
Unfortunately, that extends to things like access to politions and the ability to shape laws not just arbitrary numbers in a bank account. Extreme wealth inequality is less about a few people having more than it is about many people having less. Billionaires exist in most countries, it’s the amount of poverty that’s the issue in the US not the wealthy.
The World Bank says similar things about the global poverty rate, with that number hitting a record low of 10% in 2015.
If you are the only rich guy from the street and the rest are dead poor you should expect to get robbed and stabbed pretty soon. The same goes with governments/systems. Balance is not only a moral thing to do, it is necessary to survive.
Most revolutions have actually been about arbitrary and brutal abuse of power rather than mere wealth differences.
Because, empirically, it's a significant contributor to disutility, and a visibly selective experience of disutility is a significant contributor to social conflict. The author directly cites this—in the form of risk of revolution—as his concern, so it's if that this question comes up.
> Would it be better if everyone we're equally poor?
Maybe no inequality and ever increasing inequality aren't the only options.
Evidence? Once one's basic needs are taken care of, by far the biggest contributor to disutility and deviance/conflict is social exclusion. Now, it is also the case that social exclusion/marginalisation is significantly correlated with an unequal society - but that's a contingent fact about the late-stage-capitalist social structure we're actually in; if you actually want to fix the problem in the most effective way, by far the most sensible thing to do is to focus on social capital directly, and thus on countering social exclusion/marginalization. Sure, inequality talk is incredibly popular due to how it panders to envy, but this is not something we should encourage as it makes the actual issues a lot worse!