The original design of Tufte CSS is good, but even that won’t convince a reader to take a super bloggy blog seriously (and I’m a fan of super bloggy blogs). The design has to match the ideas and the writing.
For comparison, here’s a one-off article of mine that I published using Tufte CSS: https://thelocalyarn.com/excursus/secretary/posts/web-books....
It’s my own thing, so obviously I’m biased. But I can say objectively: A) I didn't dick around with the original Tufte design, B) I rewrote it for a year until I felt it was telling a coherent message, C) to me it is much easier to look at than the above (why would that be?) D) it was very well received E) in the 3 (?) years since I wrote it, I haven’t written anything else for which I felt like Tufte CSS would be a good fit.
(Another thing to consider: the ET Book font in Tufte CSS just doesn't look very good on low-DPI displays.)
And yet, it's also demotivating to the point of being depressing. Clicking through the chain of links culminating with Polen and Racket, the sheer depth of the stack required, the learning & work, to create beautiful digital+printed books, feels like it has much to be desired :-/
Design+publishing is inherently complicated and that complexity is conserved; you make one part of it simpler, you necessarily make another part harder. This is true of print publishing and it is true of web publishing, and they each have their own stacks. Any attempt to combine the two is going to have its own complexity. For this reason most people aren't interested in going there, so the tooling can seem very rudimentary compared with the tools that exist in either medium in isolation.
Pollen and Racket seemed arcane at first. But both are elegant, well-documented tools with extremely helpful communities. Delving into them has been probably the most rewarding experience I’ve had with anything computer-related, and that experience is still ongoing.
Your header interacts unexpectedly with the sidenotes and some of the images -- https://imgur.com/a/bgLRcvD
I tested on Safari 12 and Firefox 66; The book flipping video did not demonstrate that behavior.
In regards to font sizes, there are 5: H1s, H2s, H3s, body text, and captions.
Edit: Ahhh, and the paragraph lead ins makes 6 different sizes. That should be adjusted.
For my own web site I gave up for the time being and am living with DokuWiki's default theme. But I'm planning to give it another try over Easter.
h3 seems to similar to body text. Maybe because the top and bottom margin is almost identical
Maybe reduce/remove the paragraph gaps inside the block quotes and brighten up the citation.
Here’s a link to one article on my blog as an example: