Ask Hn: Why do startup has Programming Challenge as part of hiring?
https://indinero.com/jobs/backend-engineer
http://www.quora.com/challenges
https://indinero.com/jobs/backend-engineer
http://www.quora.com/challenges
When we are hiring we always insist on code to accompany the CV/resume. We set an incredibly simple coding task - it should take no more than 10 minutes, usually 2 - and require the code to be submitted with the job application. Without it we find that 9/10 (roughly) applicants can't program the simplest of solutions. With the requirement, 9/10 can. Yes, we get people who clearly cheat.
======== ======== ======== ========
Clickables:
I think the practice of "write this program before we'll talk to you" is largely driven by technical staff who don't understand how to run an interview where a discussion of theory and practice can suss out someone who doesn't actually have the experience. Hell, even if they don't have a language under their belt if they can pass the theory & practice Q&A I have every confidence that they can pick it up and fake it enough in the meantime.
I've had bad hires before - lazy, conceptually challenged, addicted to crystal meth - but all of them could have passed a functional programming test. Sure, you'd like to be hiring the "excellent" programmers - but a basic functional test isn't going to highlight them anyway - and may very well drive them away from you.
I should note that I don't have a problem with asking for code samples - that's a good practice I think, I do it myself. Just the complete this arbitrary test style.
When they came for interview we asked them to use whatever editor they liked to write and compile code. Some used pico, some used nano, some used vi, some used emacs, one used NotePad on their Windows laptop and transferred the code using a USB drive.
We asked them to write a program that read a file of bytes and write a second file, of exactly the same size, where each byte was incremented by a number. The two file names and the amount by which to increment are to be given on the command line.
They were told in advance that they would be asked to do something like this, and they had 'net access to look stuff up, as well as man pages.
We found that of 17 applicants, 15 couldn't do it.
If you have a 2/17 record with a placement agency you stop using them, right?
+ SF bay hires
We're not in the bay area. We're really, really not in the bay area.
+ sourced mostly from internal recommendations
We have no internal recommendations - most people who work here don't know any other programmers.
+ placement agencies we had a good track record with
We have zero placement agencies with good records.
+ AFAIK never bulk advertised ones
We have to - we have no other source of applicants.
An obvious hypothesis is that if you want to employ programmers other than in the bay area, you're screwed.
An obvious hypothesis is that if you want to employ programmers other than in the bay area, you're screwed.
For the record, I've also hired folks in Boston, Boulder and Washington, DC with similar experiences. I'll admit, though, that the average quality in SF was the best.
But, on a serious note, it shows a little bit of drive and willingness to put forth some effort into your application. It also serves as an initial filter, helping the company to target potential employees that perhaps think like they do or, something. It also filters out people that can't actually program simple solutions.
How is it not useful to have some sort of programming challenge?
On a related note, since you mentioned Indinero there, if you notice at the bottom of that page, you'd have found this link https://indinero.com/gettingtoknowyou which is very accurate of why a cultural fit and coding skill can make or break a startup in its first steps.
As about other startups that have challenges, it's pretty easy to find. Quite a bit of YC startups are starting to do it - of course, a blog, github and twitter are helpful these days.
Dropbox, Justin.tv, and more recently Greplin also have challenges as well. As a rule of thumb, here is the url nomenclature to find such challenges: "http://www.startup-name.{com|whatever}/jobs
Problem Solver. These are the group of people that all startups are looking to hire. In a way they love the programming challenge and want to prove themselves. They could potential rock the startup! Sometimes a bigger ego comes as a package for these talented individuals, be prepare to nurse.
Job Seeker. They just want to get job, since you mentioned it. They will google, hack, etc.. anything to get it out so they can secure an interview. If they are to do it on the spot, not sure how many can really pass it again. Much work is required to filter them to find the one. Personally, I feel if they have some form of problem solving approach, like rare diamonds they can be processed further.
Ideally a few good Problem Solvers mentoring and supported by a few learning Job Seeker delivered the best results for startups. I have never operate a successful startup before, dun take my word for it. :)