The failure of Gran Turismo 5: the power of menus and UI
arstechnica.com
arstechnica.com
What is frustrating is navigating around the dashboard page because sometimes the selector jumps to an area I'm not expecting based on the direction I pressed on the d-pad. Also, some shortcuts could have been implemented to make buying cars for races easier but it's not much different from previous titles in the Gran Turismo franchise.
My only gripe with the game has been that you can't invite someone into a game in online play. Call of Duty makes this very simple and GT5 missed it by a long shot. Hopefully an update will fix this but I doubt it.
Otherwise, the game has been great and I'm having a blast playing it.
I consider it one of the better games for 15-20 year olds because it is incredibly educational with respect to the aspects of driving in general. The game is packed with great technical commentary.
I'm not really a fan of console gaming, but GT series has that perfect mix of simulation and arcade not found in any other series. Pure simulation kinda sucks, since you get black flagged for doing anything..,and arcade is just boring since it's just plain unrealistic...you might as well get a game racing spaceships. .
Gran Turismo is the grandaddy, and I still look back incredibly fondly to the old Gran Turismo games. But the place to get that game now is Forza. Definitely for the Top Gear fan that wants to drive cars as "realistically" as possible on a video game console (there's neat hardcore stuff in the PC realm to check out as well, but they're definitely not as accessible as a Forza).
I would be happy to hear that GT5 has taken the training wheels off and amped up the realism of the driving model. But with GT5: Prologue, I could easily demonstrate poor driving that was forgiven by GT5: Prologue that would spin me out in the more stringently realistic Forza model.
Like you, I tried Forza and haven't looked back. Sure, there are far more realistic driving sims on Windows, but FM is really easy to get into and it is FUN. Which is what gaming is all about.
All that said, I'd actually support Legion's advice. For someone who doesn't really care much either way, a 360 is a better bet and Forza 3 is OK if you like a more arcadey experience (though I'd just get Project Gotham Racing 4 instead - it's far better if you like it arcadey, I got many hours out of it).