I expect their definition of 'evil' will quickly change.
They're domestic public servants, not clandestine agents operating overseas. Why shouldn't their position in the government and means of email/phone/postal contact be part of the public record?
Pranks will be appropriately addressed, by the very same public servants you're okay with being nameless and faceless.
The value of the data they're looking to leverage is that this information or even a close approximation of it simply isn't available.
They're going from 0 to 2. If public contact information was available, it'd be more of a 1 to 1.5-2 value.
Public servants should be respected, but they also need to be visible and accountable. Anonymity precludes that.
I don't think that's an irrational position to hold.
For a person to become a police officer they will take on much more risk to their families and property. I'd imagine the personality type that doesn't fear this risk is the exact type of officer one wouldn't want on the street.
Recruiting officers will also be more difficult which means pay/benefits must be increased (which cities often don't have) or quality of candidate accepted must decrease (putting inferior/riskier cops on the street in a position of power).
And why is that? Why are LEO disliked or having to live in fear? Shouldn't a society support the members of itself who willingly take on a role to protect said society?
Perhaps it's that the populous is increasingly seeing the police apparatus as the enforcement arm of a shadowy, unaccountable bureaucracy in bed with corporations and the elite, and not a force for the protection of the public.
So again, who's who and what they do in the government should be publicly accessible.
Because by definition, their job puts them in close adversarial contact with people inclined to breaking the law and violence.