Right. It's Amazon's fault for bringing in high-paying jobs. Definitely has nothing to do with local politics.
Right. It's Amazon's fault for bringing in high-paying jobs. Definitely has nothing to do with local politics.
The city severely restricts the housing supply; housing costs go up; the people look for a scapegoat; and there is Amazon, handily enough, when the real fault is voters's. (http://cityobservatory.org/homevoters-v-the-growth-machine/).
A real pity: https://jakeseliger.com/2015/09/24/do-millennials-have-a-fut...
Contrast this with San Francisco where people routinely shut down housing construction over frivolous objections.
It's like someone fed a bunch of pictures of apartment complexes into a generative adversarial network and built whatever it output. But kudos to them building in the first place rather than doing the San Francisco shuffle.
I completely agree that the new, large, flat, monolithic buildings are not very visually pleasing, but I wonder if two generations from now people will look back at them longingly. Maybe they won't last that long.
I live in East Village and it's basic five floor brick walk-ups everywhere.
You either build wide or you build tall. If you can only have a 200x200 feet footprint, then building a 30 story building on that footprint is 5x more efficient than building a 6 story building on that footprint.
I mean if I told you, "hey build apartments. Hopefully that means all the rents will go down." -- isn't that actually a disincentive to build, as not as much $$$ could be made after costs of development?
Now, with the right mix of upzoning, public housing, rent control, and social services, the threat doesn't have to hurt anyone, but in San Francisco and in Seattle we're not doing remotely near enough to ensure the people on the low end aren't hurt by the prosperity.
Would you rather live in a society where everyone just gets enough to survive, or one where everyone gets enough to survive, half can afford basic consumer goods, and the other half can afford luxury consumer goods?
A significant number of people would genuinely pick the former. Some people really do think the pursuit of equality is just even if it makes everyone worse off.
That's not a fair description of the criticism. Amazon isn't "bad" for providing people high-paying jobs, Amazon is bad for dumping the financial pollution from their high-paying jobs in downtown Seattle. Those are not the same thing.
It's possible to recognize that high wages for employees are great, but to also to recognize that these high-wage earners drive the cost of living up for all nearby residents, and since those residents can't also work for Amazon they have no recourse.
Most cities would kill for this so-called "financial pollution".
They absolutely do. Higher income folks can outbid and outpay for all basic essential services, driving the price of those services higher.
Compare the cost of daycare in Seattle, for example, to the equivalent cost in say Michigan.
> Unwillingness to accommodate growing populations
Seattle is #1 in urban housing construction, nationwide. https://www.seattletimes.com/business/real-estate/seattle-to... This isn't California, blaming lack of housing construction is not a valid argument.
> Most cities would kill for this so-called "financial pollution".
Their governments would, true. Most of their residents would not, because they'd have to bear the cost of the higher income residents. (See how most people's reaction to the Amazon HQ2 search was, "please not here")
By why does bidding have to happen in the first place? Because there isn't enough supply. If increase of supply matches increase of demand, the price doesn't go up. Cities like Seattle have built a lot of housing but there's still more to be done. Seattle only built one unit of housing for every 3 jobs added. At least it's not as bad as San Francisco where only one unit of housing has been added for every 6 jobs.
> Their governments would, true. Most of their residents would not, because they'd have to bear the cost of the higher income residents. (See how most people's reaction to the Amazon HQ2 search was, "please not here")
Er, no, most people really did want Amazon to move there. New York is the exception not the norm, probably because the fallacious belief that well paying jobs causes costs to rise is generally more prevalent among so-called progressives (which disproportionately live in liberal cities).
No, Seattle proves that even if you get everybody with a pulse building apartment buildings, you still can't build enough supply to soak up the excess capital.
For example: Why is there a shortage of daycare in Seattle? There's no shortage of space for it. https://www.seattletimes.com/business/developers-struggle-to... There's no shortage of demand for daycare - https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/you-should-get-on-... . And all those Amazon employees are flush with cash.
"Daycare centers will just pay more for labor, to hire more people" you say. "This money will trickle down to everyone that way" -- except it doesn't work that way - https://www.foxbusiness.com/personal-finance/broken-economic... . Just because Amazon people can afford high rates, doesn't mean everyone can. So daycare becomes broken for everyone, despite the "benefits" of the extra cash.
It turns out that situations can be more complicated than "ECON 101: everything is just supply vs demand". I'm using daycare as an example above, but you can repeat this for lots of things (healthcare, housing, transportation, etc). This is how high income earners can "break" an economy with higher cost of living, despite not doing anything wrong themselves. And this isn't a hypothetical situation, this is how the problem is actually playing out today, across most mid-sized to major cities in the US nationwide.
But the point is, there's still a shortage. It's not the mere fact that wealthy people exist that is causing the cost of daycare to go up. It's the fact that there isn't enough daycare. If the demand for daycare went up and the supply didn't change then daycare would have gotten more expensive with or without Amazon.
> "Daycare centers will just pay more for labor, to hire more people" you say. "This money will trickle down to everyone that way" -- except it doesn't work that way - https://www.foxbusiness.com/personal-finance/broken-economic.... . Just because Amazon people can afford high rates, doesn't mean everyone can. So daycare becomes broken for everyone, despite the "benefits" of the extra cash.
Sure wealthy people may be the only ones they can afford scarce goods and services, but wealthy people don't directly cause through scarcity. Scarcity is caused by lack of supply relative to demand. A sudden influx of residents increases demand, but this is fixed by increasing supply.
I'm really confused at why you're using this as an example of how the rules of supply and demand don't apply. This is a perfect example of of how supply and demand functions: demand for daycare increases, but supply doesn't grow to meet it. The price goes up. Exactly as what we would expect based on the rules of supply and demand.
So, by your logic, demand for daycare workers should rise, supply hasn't grown to meet demand, so the wages for daycare workers should spike up. Exactly what you would "expect".
Except it hasn't. Daycare wages are effectively flat. (In real world dollars, they're actually dropping, once you factor in CoL/inflation).
If "everything is just basic supply and demand", how do you explain all the instances like this where supply and demand are fundamentally broken.
https://www.king5.com/article/news/local/parents-struggling-...
You're changing topics. In the previous comment you were talking about the price of daycare, now you're talking about the wages of daycare workers. Those are two different markets. Perhaps there's plenty of people willing to work as daycare workers, but there aren't enough daycare centers being opened because of restrictive permitting processes. So the supply of daycare workers is still high (and thus, wages don't go up) but the supply of daycare centers is insufficient.
A daycare, like any other business has costs associated with rent (which has gone up a LOT) and employees (who are taking care of my kids and should be paid a decent living wage in a rising-cost-of-living environment).
What evidence do you have that they are price gouging rather than simply trying to maintain a working business. Why do you think adding more daycares would significantly change this dynamic?
Are there operational costs that make operating a daycare at lower than $X per child per day unprofitable? Maybe. If it's rent then the discussion shifts to the supply of real estate. If it's wages then it's about the accessibility of labor.
Housing isn't as easy to create as normal products. There's a multi-year lag time to get new housing built. Here in Seattle we just had a number of high-rise luxury apartments open right next to Amazon's HQ within ~6 months of each other. As a result, rents in the area flatlined for a period. It was a good thing.
Those apartments were initially conceived probably ~3-5 years ago. 5 years ago AMZN was a $150B company, now it's worth 6x as much. If you had a time machine and could go back 10 years and look at how fast Amazon would grow in the 2010s, you'd absolutely invest massively in housing. We didn't have one, instead housing prices skyrocketed along with the rise of this one company that dominates our local economy.
> probably because the fallacious belief that well paying jobs causes costs to rise is generally more prevalent among so-called progressives
Are you trying to argue that Amazon's growth has no impact on the cost of living in Seattle? How is this a 'belief' thing? There is a preponderance of evidence that the rise in the tech sector in Seattle has dramatically increased housing prices here.
There are individual cities that have larger populations than the entirety of Washington State that have lower rents than Seattle. Demand does not cause higher prices , lack of supply causes prices.
Like I said in my original comment, if we had known how much was coming down the pike, we'd have started the process of building more housing immediately. We did not (and could not) know, so we're doing the next best thing and building as much as possible right now.
Your argument about individual cities is a red herring. Show me a city that went through a similar level of high wage worker growth in such a short amount of time and somehow managed to build enough housing to keep housing prices flat.
A rapid spike in demand will probably be accompanied with a temporary increase in cost as supply catches up, but it will not result in long-term cost increases unless the supply is constrained. Seattle, San Francisco, Portland, etc. are not dense cities by any means. If apartment buildings are taking 10 years to get built then there is massive mismanagement or onerous regulation going on.
There has been a rise in Seattle restaurant prices, but that was clearly due to the many new burdens placed on them by the city government.
If there's money to be made from increased demand, businesses will appear to satisfy it, resulting in no increase in prices. In other words, prosperity does not cause inflation.
The price rises in Seattle are in real estate, and that's because the government artificially restricts the supply of it.
Not clearly. Much of the Seattle boom had a lot to do with Chinese investment. This recently took a downturn, with new Chinese politics and policies. Investment crashed, along with a bunch of luxury services and businesses (within the last year). Now you have areas that were traditionally high income, fueled by a combination of high-tech, medical, foreign investment, etc and fewer and fewer jobs and opportunities. The areas like Bellevue are struggling to keep expanding the high income standards without collapsing under the low-income needs and with fewer resources to power the bubble. Talking about AMZ is an abstract, since anyone blaming AMZ has a misunderstanding of the economics, for a partisan fairy tale. A high tide caused prices (and taxes) to rise and not all of them have fallen with the economic churn. While some of it is the govt, not all of it, imo.
As someone in Seattle that pays for daycare, that's a terrible example if you're trying to prove your point. Seattle has some of the highest daycare costs in the country, and it's largely because the overhead costs (due to intense bureaucracy) means Seattle's supply of daycare is absolutely terrible for a city of its size.
I think this was only true for other deeply NIMBY cities like NYC and Boston. Other places are desperate for "financial pollution"/"economic opportunities".
Take a population where everyone makes $20k per year. Great! It’s equal!
Take another population where half make $30k and half make $50k. Oh no! Inequality!
I’d rather be in the 2nd population.
The folks making $30k in the second population may now be spending a bunch more in childcare and hours more on their commutes, because they've been priced out of the city and now have travel from further away.
As an example: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/17/business/economy/san-fran...
Pricing people is not an inevitable consequence of population growth, it's the consequence of an older generation of haves deciding that younger and less wealthy people do not deserve housing in a city.
Which, given that it seems to happen pretty much everywhere, must be factored into decision making.
"Wouldn't it be nice if humans didn't act like humans" is the sort of dreamy optimism that kills Communism.
You can have high inequality without prices rising - it’s a separate problem.
I don’t think inequality is inherently evil, but it’s critical that we prioritize increasing the supply of all essential goods and services (housing, medical care, education) to create prosperity for everyone and prevent the have-nots from suffering. Via inequality, we can reward people for creating prosperity, but it’s important that this excess wealth only bids up the price of luxuries like yachts and art, not basic needs.
In my experience, the people that support these housing policies are the kind that would rather everyone have $20k instead of $30k/$50k. Opposition to building denser housing is generally more prevalent with "progressives". At least judging from my experience in San Francisco.
There's nothing environmentalist about low density sprawl.
Same with Rose Pak. Sure she maybe owned property, but she didn’t derive her power from it.