The please bargain system is nothing but institutionalized blackmail, and many innocent people have become its victims.
The please bargain system is nothing but institutionalized blackmail, and many innocent people have become its victims.
The please bargain system does neither of that.
To answer your question, not "we" would do that but that's what fair trials are intended for.
I was laying out reasons why the plea bargain system is principally unjust. There are many more problems with the US justice system, of course.
In reality, the guideline ranges stipulated in the plea bargain put him most likely under 2 years, and possibly as few as 6 months. Even with the maximum upward departure stipulated in the agreement, Hutchins would not be looking at 3 years.
The guilty get the benefit of reduced sentences. The innocent have to face the bullying behavior where prosecutors stack up charges to make the potential punishment more frightening in order to coerce a plea.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201...