I don’t think the math works that way. Suppose your return is 35% after paying the long term tax rate. This implies your pre-tax return was .35/(1-.25) = 46.66. Now instead pay the short-term rate and get 46.66 * (1-.4) = 28%. So the return drops from 35% to 28%, which is still mind-boggling (even 20% over decades would be extremely impressive).