That's a good idea, but it won't work for a non-constructive proof.
If I remember correctly, in the semi-regular survey conducted with CS experts about this question, the most likely explanation that accompanied a response saying they believed that it may be the case that P=NP was “...but with very large constants”.
I especially distrust non-constructive proofs that involve first constructing objects in an impossible manner (like, say, sorting an infinite set of infinitely long bit strings—I'm looking at you, Cantor)—and then (ab-)using the reader's intuition about actual things you can construct to "prove" nonsense about things you clearly can't.
Which is a long way of saying that I'll only accept a constructive proof that P != NP (or vice versa).