> Do they seriously believe that Intel and AMD and ARM have all screwed up by supporting vectorization?
The benefit of vectorization of course depends on the total workload. In a web/application server where e.g. 5% of resources is spent on encryption and 95% on other things like networking it could very well be that enabling vectorization and thus having lower clock speeds results in decreased performance.
> You might run into an anti-vectors campaigner who wants to take this freedom away
I really don't see much campaigning in the slides, that merely say:
> We do not give a machine code implementation using SSE etc
> – We (and others) have found that using these extensions causes overall performance of cryptographic systems to slow down
> – Just looking at run times of algorithms on their own is not a good measure of overall performance in the wild
> – Would caution NIST against putting too much emphasis on academic measures of performance of algorithms for this reason
I don't see any indication they're against the option of vectorization, but merely warn that systems performance is going to be what matters, and not just the algorithm.