Nor did the companies ever take responsibility for
their products. In Shell’s study, the firm argued
that the “main burden” of addressing climate change
rests not with the energy industry, but with
governments and consumers. That argument might have
made sense if oil executives, including those from
Exxon and Shell, had not later lied about climate
change and actively prevented governments from
enacting clean-energy policies.
If there is a lever to make things better, and I stop you from knowing about that lever, I have stopped things from getting better. You can't argue that the lever might not have made things better, given that I was the person who suppressed the choice itself.Alternatively, if tax day is in two months, and you do not know tax day exists, and I know, and not only do I deliberately choose not to tell you, but I deliberately stop you from knowing, then I am responsible for you not filing your taxes on time.
> Like how do you foresee the average person reacting if they can only get 5 gallons of fuel per week,
We would have had 40 years to change to electric cars and heating, so it wouldn't matter.
> that their food selection is reduced to what's available in a 50-mile radius of where they live?
Likewise the food transport industry would have had 40 years to transition their infrastructure to a sustainable state. Indeed, we might be using primarily hydroponics-based agriculture at this point.
> That they can't have air conditioning for more than a few hours a day?
The places that require air conditioning are sunny. Indeed, the entirety of america's energy requirements could be supplied by a tiny square of solar panels in the desert, so I do not see why in 40 years, air conditioning couldn't have matured to a state where it not only requires less energy, but also was sustainable.
> These are near-apocalyptic scenarios that we're talking about if reduce our energy usage to sustainable levels.
I mean, they are now, but as I have stated repeatedly, we could have had 40 years to prepare. Now we're 2 days before tax day, scrambling to prepare for the worst, because we never really had enough warning to set us on a path to the best.