1. "Automated tests are software" 2. "all software tends to have bugs"
1. "Automated tests are software" 2. "all software tends to have bugs"
You're presumably using a whole heap of software to post your comments, all of which will tend to have bugs; yet you still find it useful.
Boolean logic rarely captures the nuances of real-world situations, and the "rounding errors" accumulate at each step of such arguments, which can lead to some silly (but logically consistent) outcomes. I think you've fallen victim to this here.
In a similar way, it's a false dichotomy to think of software as being either buggy xor perfect; of testing (or any other QA) as proving brokenness xor correctness; or to consider bugginess as implying uselessness.
Notice that I framed things in terms of confidence (in a Bayesian sense) and costs; not absolutes.