No, open source has been a "thing" for quite some time even in 1998. No, the guy just didn't get it. He asked questions like who do you sue if something goes wrong. . . where is the market incentive to create software if there is no strong intellectual property rights. . . what if someone steals the code and makes a million dollars. . . What if the original author dies starving while some rich corporation takes advantage? I mean, really silly arguments when you look back.
I told him that most of the software using this model is simply more reliable than proprietary software, but he just didn't get it. There was already plenty of "reputation" even back then, he just wasn't a hacker and couldn't understand any other perspective other than his own.