That argument supposes that high school teachers ended up with that career by looking at all job prospects and picking the one with the best economic prospects. Based on my experience, exactly none of them did that, in any field. My sophomore English teacher used to work at an aerospace company, and my biology teacher studied to be a physician, for example.
> Most great high school math teachers are doing it for pretty pure reasons. Admirable, but hard to expect from rational people.
Exactly so. Until we can reliably identify success in a field (like football wins), and then make the economic incentives align to promote that success, we can't hope to increase the number of great people in a field by economic metrics.