At least one well known Ad Blocker went down this exact same dark path before
Hey, for $$$ we'll make sure your customer don't get "lost" and go visit similar sites that are illegitimate (ie. don't pay us). What's that? Our algorithm says your site wasn't legitimate but your rival's site is? Well we can look into that for you but meanwhile try paying us $$$ and you'll be amazed at the results...
Unsurprisingly their "customers" didn't like this very much, but the AAA video games industry has learned if you do something awful, get smacked, apologise, then immediately do it again, you wear people down. The tenth time they just can't muster as much anger. "Yeah, yeah, it's just normal for companies to treat me like shit, I guess I put up with it".