If you see EMH as a general principle: all present information is incorporated in the price and all Sharpe ratios trend to the market Sharpe ratio, it makes more sense.
No one actually believes in strong EMH, that is, it’s impossible to beat the market Sharpe ratio.
The EMH isn't necessarily that every stock is perfectly priced. It's that it's not possible to reliably predict where prices will go next.
But isn't the hypothesis that it's not possible to predict because it's perfectly priced already?