IMHO, the biggest reason why Lisp never won out over imperative programming languages is exactly this attitude. Advocates of imperative programming languages took critiques of those languages seriously, while Lisp advocates wouldn't.
Take the evolution of C, for example. First, you had ALGOL, but it had problems. So someone created CPL. But that had problems, so then we had BCPL. Then B. Then C. That’s five separate languages! People on the imperative side of the language divide were willing to throw stuff out and start from scratch, over and over, until they got it right.
Lisp advocates were not.
Fortunately, the creation of Clojure suggests that a willingness to change is finally making its way into some areas of the greater Lisp community.