What does $10/share represent? Why not $1 or $30? Genuinely curious about how this sort of calculation would be made and what the assumptions are.
What does $10/share represent? Why not $1 or $30? Genuinely curious about how this sort of calculation would be made and what the assumptions are.
I once did some consulting for a very well known person in the financial services industry, a recognized leader in the field. As part of that work I got to see his financial "models". They took the form of the most incredibly complicated Excel spreadsheets I have ever encountered. They were real monsters with hundreds of thousands of rows, dozens of workbooks.
Being a software engineer, I wrote some code to reverse-engineer them. I wrote some VB to dump all the formulas as text, and then wrote a parser and code analyzer. The result was a real eye-opener. 90% of the formulas were dead code that didn't actually play into the results at all. The rest was still a mess, but when I started combing through it I discovered that even the live code didn't really matter to the results because at the end there was a "fudge factor" that the guy just set according to his gut feel about the market, and this was the main thing that determined the final result.
I didn't last long in that job.
So yes, I'm probably being a bit harsh. There are probably analysts who actually know something, and MPF is actually not totally worthless. But "it's all BS" is a pretty good first-order approximation.
The issue is that the things you're trying to model are usually extremely complex and dynamic, in a way that's fundamentally unlike most sciences where the objects of analysis obey more or less immutable laws.
So it's less like trying to model where a kicked ball will land in a football game, and more like trying to model where the ball will be after 30 seconds of passing and running.
But Michael Burry wasn't doing that, and his models weren't wrong. He correctly saw that the characteristics of the mortgage contracts that were being put into MBSs invalidated the assumption of uncorrelated defaults that were being used in the banks' and ratings agencies' models.
If you think that’s true, the natural correlary is that all companies are just flipping coins.
I imagine the basic assumption is that if the market is tapped out, revenues will slow, plateau and then begin to fall before Tesla reaches sustained profitability. That means debts will begin to grow again.
Current book value is about $26 a share, of which about $12 is cash on hand. If debt remained constant but no new cash came in, book value goes to $14 at the moment of bankruptcy. Discounting for "bankruptcy really sucks for shareholders", $10 is a fairly defensible worst-case.
That's a dramatically over simplified explanation, though. Look up divided discount model (DDM) and discounted cash flows (DCF) for more info. There are other methods as well, but most rely on the same principals.