[1] http://www.fosspatents.com/2019/05/breaking-news-federal-tra...
[1] http://www.fosspatents.com/2019/05/breaking-news-federal-tra...
FOSS Patents is written by Florian Müller: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florian_Müller_(author)
As some may recall, Müller was frequently criticized back in the day for failing to disclose conflicts of interest in his reporting. Quote from HN user gpm:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18333187
> I wouldn't trust FOSS patents and the author Florian Mueller as far as I could throw him. He has a long history of being a paid shill, lying about it, and being flat out wrong.
> (Paid by oracle) http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20120419070127103
> (Paid by microsoft) http://techrights.org/2012/08/18/vile-lobbyist/
> (Paid by apple? I can't find other/primary sources to back up this claim though it does seem likely.) https://mrpogson.com/2012/08/21/apples-paid-shillconsultant-...
> (More examples of him being wrong) http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20120820111527257
> Refuting legal arguments takes time and expertise I don't have. He's good at his job, and I have no knowledge about this case. So while I put no faith whatsoever in his analysis I can't tell you how it is wrong, and yes this is an ad hominem.
Gee, I don't know: if their modem is superior, then why shouldn't they get superior share of the market? That's not anticompetitive if they make a better product. BTW if they capture the majority share then it's totally expected that they should get "more than the rest of the industry combined."
Strangling competition and harming rivals is how you (illegally) get and maintain a superior share of the market.
And even if they're found guilty, if punishment is .0001% (or some other laughable minuscule percentage) of their revenue, its not a punishment - it's a cost of doing business.
Just because a thing can be done, doesn't mean it should.
Everything costs something. The cost here is everyone else just itching to take company X down. Zero goodwill.
Yes, they get to do that kind of thing and so does everyone else pushing back increasingly hard.
...which they just were. That’s the point of the article.
If the punishments are minuscule, it'll just be a cost of doing business. Or better yet, there may be no fines at all.
What happened with Yahoo? Equifax? Mariott? Adult Friend Finder? Target? eBay?
Each of those has hundreds of millions of people involved in massive breaches. Do they still exist? Were they fined appropriately for the impact they caused?
(Admittedly Yahoo isn't the best of examples, because they were in a downslide with no good market. But nor were they fined for a breach of every account.)
Anyway, in this case, it looks like the FTC did not seek monetary relief (not sure why), but they sought and received an injunction basically ordering Qualcomm to stop doing what they were doing, with compliance and monitoring procedures to enforce it. That’s not as dramatic as a financial penalty would have been, but the stock hit suggests that Qualcomm nevertheless will suffer as a result.
[1] https://wp.nyu.edu/compliance_enforcement/2019/03/06/the-ris...
Royalty rates aren't about their physical modems/chips. It's about their standards essential patent licensing. In this regard, it would make sense that how much they charge for these patent licenses should be more in-line with the rest of the industry.
>from the perspective of some major OEMs, more than the rest of the industry combined.
That was referring to Apple, and Qualcomm has shown Apple has some tactics of making its competitor's patents cost look a lot lower, and hence making Qualcomm's patent a lot higher.
My take is that Qualcomm, charges a lot, but unlikely to be "more than the rest of the industry combined".