Seesmic: Why it's so important to just frackin' start
calacanis.com
calacanis.com
Creation of needs and all that.
Not that I'm saying it should be put down to rest, just that it won't go anywhere in the mainstream. People that aren't in this horrid social media bubble just aren't looking past Facebook.
Not many web apps beyond Google, Yahoo, MSFT, Facebook, MySpace have much of a shot going "mainstream."
Most YC companies (in fact, none at this moment) will not go mainstream, yet several have been successful. Even a startup with a lot of traffic, like Scribd, is not mainstream, but it doesn't seem to have negatively affected them.
and see the number of video comments
Vid comments are of lower information content and of higher bandwidth... so they are of higher cost when you consume them. Also, most people don't wanna fix their hair etc to be bothered with them. Seesmic should study why video phones flopped...
i'd say that is valid for the majority of comments on the web. The exception seems to be Hacker News. Obviously that has something to do with the people not the medium, although a text comment is edited a multiple times.
I remember myself when i would scroll through the page of comments and read only the first ones, then suddenly you go through the page and must read all of them.
In the same manner although there were all these video comments i only viewed some.
It's about becoming a habit I guess.
Of course it took 15 years for people to get used or have a reason to text commenting...In few hundred! years maybe people may be will have a reason to use video phones and video commenting.
With text comments I can quickly scan the comments for interesting bits. With video comments I'm at the mercy of the commenter. I have to sit through the whole thing, watching it at whatever speed they choose to speak at rather than whatever speed I can read/scan text. It's also unsearchable.
Additionally, I think people tend to ramble more when they speak than when they're writing text that they can go back and edit.
Most of the time video just doesn't add anything to the discussion. Maybe they would be useful if the commenter needs to physically demonstrate something, or sing or recite a poem or something. But that's not the common case.
Now, if you could automatically transcribe the words from video comments and post it alongside the video (thus making watching the video optional) I wouldn't be so opposed to it. Video certainly has the potential to make the conversation a bit more personal. Sometimes it's nice to put a face to a name/comment (which could also help deter trolls)
(perhaps some sort of combination of speech recognition and crowd-sourcing could be used to transcribe video comments...)
As Ivan, PG and others said about TipJoy -- it launched relatively recently and the company is iterating through features.
How does Seesmic not deserve the same patience?
I'm not counting Seesmic out, I just don't get the hype.
Then again, who wouldn't want that attention? I'm sure TipJoy certainly would. The only bloggers I've seen with a TipJoy are either YC founders or HN readers -- which isn't a slant against TipJoy, but I'm sure they could benefit form a hype injection.