The other is just just pumping away heat.
Pumping away heat is probably better than fooling your brains thermoregulation algorithms. But maybe heatstroke is your thing.
Keyword being "feel", as opposed to "actual"
I've had random ideas like wearing a wetsuit that regulates the temperature at right at skin-level, so something like this patch is both validation and a marked improvement.
No. What matters is that your body doesn't overheat.
In the absence of devices like the watch, your feeling of being comfortable enough correlates well with your body not overheating. But if you are wearing a device like the watch that fools your body's perception of comfort, you can feel comfortable while your body is actually overheating. That's not good.
> I don't actually want to change my body temperature by 5 degrees, I'd die.
That's not what the patch does. What the patch does is keep your body from getting hotter in an environment where it otherwise would. And you can tell that it's doing that because you still feel comfortable, and the patch isn't fooling your body's perception of comfort, so if you feel comfortable, you're ok.
If you start feeling too cold, you just take the patch off. So you don't need to worry about your body temperature dropping.
Oh, so everybody stays out in the hot sun all day? Nobody stays in the shade? Nobody goes indoors? Nobody has houses designed to stay reasonably cool when it's hot out? (There are plenty of ways to do that without A/C.)
If people don't change how long they stay out--just go out for short periods to do something, then go somewhere where they can cool off--I have no objection to them using a device to help them feel more comfortable. But uncoupling your natural perception of your body's condition from the actual state of your body is always risky.
I sweat more than needed. Tricking my body into thinking it's 5 degrees cooler wouldn't make me overheat, it would just make me more comfortable.
Meaning, you get too cold when you sweat?
> Tricking my body into thinking it's 5 degrees cooler wouldn't make me overheat, it would just make me more comfortable.
Would it stop you from sweating as much?
At lower temperatures, parts of me get colder than necessary. And there's lots of room for my skin temperature to go up safely that my body is not making use of.
At higher temperatures, I'm already past saturation on evaporation, and the excess just dehydrates me.
> Would it stop you from sweating as much?
Well I sweat less when it's colder. So whatever definition of 'feeling' colder is necessary to cause that effect, that's the definition I choose.
Then you wouldn't want to wear a device that made you feel even colder, would you?
> At higher temperatures, I'm already past saturation on evaporation, and the excess just dehydrates me.
And making you feel cooler would not change that your body is not actually being cooled--if you're at saturation, your body can't cool itself. So to avoid your body overheating, you would need to go someplace that is actually cooler. Just making you feel cooler wouldn't help. (You might get some increase in the time you could stay outside if your body sweated less and therefore dehydrated less.)
Yes I would, because five degrees colder than that is still comfortable, but being wet is not comfortable.
> And making you feel cooler would not change that your body is not actually being cooled--if you're at saturation, your body can't cool itself. So to avoid your body overheating, you would need to go someplace that is actually cooler. Just making you feel cooler wouldn't help. (You might get some increase in the time you could stay outside if your body sweated less and therefore dehydrated less.)
I'm not asking the device to magically prevent overheating. I'm saying that the lower amount of sweat wouldn't be a downside, because there would still be enough.
Also I don't actually overheat because I slow down and avoid pushing myself to that point.
This is a tangent anyway, it's the slightly-over-room-temperature situation that I really care about.