Data hoarders are certainly a segment but as a long time what.cd member I completely stopped downloading music once I had a spotify subscription. For me, torrenting was an inconvenient means to an ends (low cost unlimited access to music)
Another big change for me was the industry got wise to leaks. Now when an album leaks, the labels have a plan to immediately offer it for streaming on a major service or even media partner like NPR.
One of the major values of private Audio trackers was you got to hear stuff way before other people. Even this has been largely taken away. (Though sometimes the previews are now only a few songs)