1) In the absence of this pairing it just looks like a government-growing cash grab to a segment of the population.
2) People who aren't even convinced of the dangers of AGW can still support it.
1) In the absence of this pairing it just looks like a government-growing cash grab to a segment of the population.
2) People who aren't even convinced of the dangers of AGW can still support it.
But there's massive opposition.
There seem to be two main arguments:
1. The tax is too small to make any real difference, so we might as well scrap it. (I don't understand this one either, and it's only true for current levels, the tax is supposed to increase every year.)
2. China and the States aren't anything, so anything we do is meaningless and just disadvantages us. (The answer to this argument is Nobel prize winning Bill Nordhaus's carbon club proposal)
It looks like the carbon tax opposing conservatives are going to win the election in October. It'll be a shameful time to be a Canadian. We have the highest CO2 emissions per capita and most of the country won't be doing anything about it.
If the tax becomes large enough to make a real difference to how people live, then there would be enough public support to scrap it, or at the very least freeze any increases. That means it'll only work if technology advances fast enough that we can lower our emissions enough to meet climate goals without compromising quality of life. But that would be a reduction of over 10% a year, every year. Yeah, that's what "limiting to 2C" would actually mean. http://www.climatecodered.org/2014/01/radical-emissions-redu...
Trudeau has also supported the oil industry at every turn. The extraction and burning of the remaining oil in Canada is itself more than Canada's fair share of global emissions to limit heating to 2C. https://www.nationalobserver.com/2015/07/08/news/tar-sands-v...
As for the carbon club, existing agreements like NAFTA stand in the way of creating a carbon-pricing trade bloc. The most plausible place for it to start would be the EU after the UK leaves, but even then, I doubt there will be any politicians fighting for it - for similar reasons as for Canada.
And, of course, even something that is revenue-neutral overall will have some winners and losers: SUV owners will pay more than those commuting with public transport. Poorly isolated single-family homes in the south relying on air conditioning through the summer will be more expensive compared to flats in northern brick houses, etc.
And this is liberal, polite, progressive Canada, doing a case-study in how Conservatives fight against even the most conservative of carbon pricing policies.
Those all sound like excellent outcomes in terms of linking behavior to carbon emissions via a price-signaling mechanism.
Logically, it's impossible to simultaneously incentivize people to emit less and not have the current high emitters feel some incentive to change.
(Edit: removed one extraneous negation in the last sentence.)
In general it takes more energy to live in colder climates than warmer ones.
So a better comparison would probably be a large house up north vs a small apartment down south.
BC’s tax was gradually introduced, starting at a low rate. Also, the government of the time gave rural and low income people a large credit right away. I was poor at the time on account of being a startup founder (LoL) and I recall getting hundreds of dollars in the mail very soon after the tax launched.