Is it the case that lawyers don't want anyone to understand the technical issues, but they only have the ability to get rid of potential jurors, not judges?
Is it the case that lawyers don't want anyone to understand the technical issues, but they only have the ability to get rid of potential jurors, not judges?
The more uniform your audience is, the better chance you have to craft an argument that will work with all of them.
Suppose the trial involves some specialized field, and you have a jury with a wide range of knowledge about that field. Both plaintiff and defendant are going to include in their cases an explanation of the relevant field, pitched for the backgrounds of the jurors with the least prior knowledge.
If the jury also has people who are experts in that field, there are at least three potential problems.
1. They are going to be bored during the part where you are explaining the field to the rest of the jury, and might let their minds wander, and might miss something important.
2. Your primer on their field necessarily simplifies things, and if you simplify in a different way than they would, it could prejudice them against your case.
3. The other jurors may turn to them for guidance on the evidence relating to that field. That's problematical for two reasons.
3a. If the evidence relating to the field is in an area where experts in that field disagree, the other jurors will get the position of the expert juror, and will probably give that more weight than the testimony of exports at trial who take a different position.
In effect, the expert juror ends up also as a de facto expert witness in the trial--but an expert witness not subject to examination or cross examination.
3b. There is a danger that if the jury turns to the expert juror for help on the technical evidence, they will also tend to give more weight to that juror's opinion on the rest of evidence.
It makes me curious-- suppose the judge asks a potential juror if there is any reason they cannot remain impartial. What happens if that potential juror responds yes, pointing out that the plantiff's lawyer had clearly been systematically dismissing the independent thinkers from the jury for the past four hours?
For example, say the defendant asserts that a patent is "obvious." "Obviousness" has a precise legal definition: it means that every element of a patent claim was disclosed in a combination of prior art references. Where multiple references must be combined to arrive at the invention, there usually must be a showing that one of ordinary skill in the art would be motivated to combine the references in the necessary manner. The court will decide what elements are required by the patent claims and what references are prior art, and the experts will opine on what elements are disclosed in which prior art references and whether there is any motivation to combine them. The jury takes that information and decides the ultimate question of obviousness.
That process absolutely requires the jury to "understand the technical issues." During trial, evidence about how the accused product works will be shown in slides right next to the patent claim language. Jurors will be repeatedly told that they must find that every element of the patent claim is practiced by the accused product. If jurors don't understand the technology well enough to map between the accused product and the patent claims, they are not going to return a verdict for the patent owner. (You will almost never see an appeal in a patent case where the patent required doing "X" and the accused product simply did not do "X." The fight is always about the scope of what it means to do "X.")
But that understanding must be based only on the evidence presented. The risk with jurors who have domain knowledge in specific fields is that they will substitute their own knowledge and preconceptions for the evidence, and when that happens, you get a verdict that is not based on the evidence presented--which is curated to meet legal requirements--but based on an unknowable body of information in the juror's head.
There is also no need for jurors to bring personal expertise to bear on a case. A jury of 12 ordinary people can understand surprisingly complex subject matter when they have Ivy-league PhDs explaining it to them, and do nothing but focus on the subject all day for a week or two at a time. What they may lack is domain knowledge. But if there is pertinent knowledge, it is the party's job to put that knowledge in front of the jury. The jury must simply be able to understand it once it has been presented.
As to your last point--if the judge doesn't understand your technology, she will assume it is bullshit and find ways to throw out your case. (Most cases don't make it to a jury trial.) Parties go to great lengths to explain the technology to judges, for example, through lengthy tech tutorials and the like.
Which is why Jury Selection is an "art" and both sides are involved: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_selection
It's possible for public experts to voice their opinion in an brief amici curiae. They don't need to be unbiased, but they're supposed to be independent from the parties.
There are some stats that 80% of such statements are accepted, although it's up to the courts discretion how and if they make it into discovery. It certainly helps for a "both sides try to hide some aspect from judge and jury" situation though.
Norway has always had a combination of juries and panels of judges that are made up of a mix of legally trained professional judges and 'lay judges'.
Now it is that system only. The lay judges are people who are appointed the same way as jurors used to be, but the difference is that deliberations happens with professional judges present.
The lay judges have a majority, but the professional judges can under certain circumstances overrule if they find the lay judges are ignoring the instructions or otherwise rendering a sentence clearly not supported by the law.
On one side it means jury nullification is generally out, but on the other hand we regularly both see cases where the professional judges call out clearly faulty logic, as well as cases where the lay judges overrule the professional judges and the judgement stands (meaning the professional judges disagreed but accepts that the decision followed the legal requirements).
To me, seeing the decisions of the professional judges when they override makes jury trials terrifying. And this is with professional judges present in the room and participating in the deliberations. Even that is insufficient to deter flawed decisions.
What we've seen in Norway when the professional judges set aside decisions is exactly that their dissenting opinions often reveal that even when professional judges are participating in the discussions the lay judges still occasionally insist on decisions that are obviously logically invalid.
Also given how blatantly ridiculous some jury decisions can be - the last ever jury decision in a Norwegian court was a combination of two yes/no answers where the jury entered the only combination that was a logical impossibility based on their instructions as a guilty finding on the first charge was a pre-requisite to make the second charge applicable; people were quite relieved that the last jury decision basically helped validate the decision to get rid of them by failing to follow even those basic instructions.
It makes me wonder how many jury decisions have been based on invalid reasoning but where the outcome is just plausible enough to allow the judgement to stand.
Personally I think juries will be looked back on as a dark chapter.
1. It isn't actually relevant to the case or for the purpose of rendering judgement on the case.
2. Someone didn't do their job.
I think (2) is sort of the leap of faith required for our legal system, lawyers are required to advocate solely for their charge and empowered to do what is required to earn them an optimal outcome. There are many times this doesn't happen (see overburdened court appointed lawyers) but I think that's a flaw in our current implementation of the system rather than the system itself - it actually all falls together pretty well as a logical solution.
"A jury of one's peers" originally meant people from your community, people who knew you, thus coming in with lots of relevant knowledge.
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/a%20jury%20of%20o...
> Beginning in the later 1400s, the development of the jury trial, with witnesses testifying about the facts of a particular case was an important factor in the development of the hearsay rule. Interesting, it appears that prior to the later 1400s juries conducted their own investigations in civil cases.
> Toward the end of the Middle Ages, the function of the jury transformed from persons who were active investigators that had knowledge of the case to our present day juries who are passive triers of fact with no prior knowledge of the case presented.
I've seen brilliant people struggle to understand certain technologies. So really, we're relying on both sides bringing in experts who sound convincing (perhaps because they have fancy degrees) and then having them fight to convince a jury with zero expertise.
Seems silly to me, compared to the alternative of just having judges what specialize in these things make the decisions.
Yes, that requires a lot of "teaching" of the non-expert jury during the trial. But that's perfectly fine, because the purpose of a jury trial is not so much getting a verdict that is "better" in some objective sense than whatever an expert panel would come up with, but to create a process where the public at large feels represented and is able to follow the proceedings and trust the results.
(that is a good analogy though - and you hit the core point, the lawyers need to endow the judge or jurors with an expertise or understanding of any matter that is core to the judgement being decided)
Pretty sure this accurately describes the situation.