Astronomers Find First Possible Evidence Of Other Universes
technologyreview.com
technologyreview.com
I recommend the writings of Max Tegmark on philosophical cosmology. He's an exceptional popular science writer and doesn't dumb it down. http://space.mit.edu/home/tegmark/crazy.html The Multiverse Hierarchy is probably where to start.
I read things like this, and I can't help but think it's just wrong (and that whatever science is saying is being distorted). Time did not start 13.7 billion years ago, and space didn't just pop into existence then. To suggest that suggests something came from nothing.
So I can only assume that when science says space and time, they don't literally mean space and time, sort of like how science and laymen differ in their use of the word theory.
In this case, I assume "space and time" being created 13.7 billion years ago means space and time that we can see, as we know it, and following our rules (whatever that is).
Quantum physics, Relativity and Cosmology all have an annoying characteristic, which is that they're not intuitive. Quantum physics is unintuitive because things don't behave classically (i.e. like pebbles) at that scale, instead they behave like wave-particles. Relativity is unintuitive because space and time are tightly linked together and this is not an effect that we observe during the course of our daily lives. Cosmology is unintuitive because the timescales and concepts it deals with are so mind-boggling.
So I can only assume that when science says space and time, they don't literally mean space and time, sort of like how science and laymen differ in their use of the word theory.
Nope, they do mean space and time. And yes, they do mean that something came from nothing - or rather, if you study the topic, that something came from <X> where <X> is unknowable.
Interestingly, this leaves a pretty good place for that "God" concept to hide.
> And yes, they do mean that something came from nothing - or rather, if you study the topic, that something came from <X> where <X> is unknowable.
See, that's what I have an issue with. Just because we can't record something or didn't record something doesn't mean it doesn't/didn't exist. We just haven't found a way to measure it. So something happens some time ago called the big bang, changing the layout of the universe. This doesn't mean time or stuff didn't exist before that. It simply means things changed.
I know I'm stepping on toes and making light a topic people spend their lives pondering, but while concepts of time make for interesting theories, time isn't anything but a human concept that we've categorized. Thought games make time something you can fool with, but I've never read anything regarding showing time as anything that can be manipulated (granted, while I love reading this stuff, it's far outside my field).
The concept of string theory is, at the very least, something which can be measured at some point. Time, however, is something that cannot be manipulated.
Of course, as mentioned, this isn't my field so please, take these comments as merely that: and uninformed but interested outsider.
No, that's what I'm saying. You don't understand this concept of spacetime, because it is not intuitive, and so you do not "get" the reality that the physics (which has ample amounts of supporting evidence and is not in doubt) predicts.
Time can easily be manipulated, and it is manipulated all the time. Travel at the speed of light, and time ceases to pass for you. Travel really close to the speed of light and time will pass much more slowly for you. See the twin's paradox (which is only a paradox because it contradicts our intuition) for an easily understandable example of why. This effect (time dilation) is proven by mountains of evidence in the form of decay rates of particles, which change depending on their speed. It is not up for argument. Any subsequent theory must explain this observed effect.
So, back to the initial question, your intuitive understanding of "time" is what is faulty. We have this perception of "time passing", but as far as we know that may just be an illusion in our heads. The only physical principle that has a clear direction in time is the increase of entropy. Time clearly exists, but the constant, measured passing of time is something that our brains made up to make sense of the world. There is no more necessity for time to exist than there is for for a balloon to exist. Time can be stretched, squeezed, and otherwise messed with. And it can even cease to exist.
Yes, this is hard to wrap your head around. Welcome to physics.
My understanding is this is all about perception. But basically, it's all about my perception of someone traveling at the speed of light as seeming to slow down. Even you say it: time ceases to pass for you as a perception. If I travel away from you at the speed of light, you cease to move as I see it, but you are still really moving.
Or am I off the mark here?
Yeah, here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_travel#Time_travel_to_the_...
"These theories state that, relative to a given observer, time passes more slowly for bodies moving quickly relative to that observer, or bodies that are deeper within a gravity well."
That seems pretty straight forward, but is flawed to think that suggests time passes more slowly, only the perception of it does. I've read up a number of tests but from what I remember, they all discuss verifying this perception of slowed time as being accurate rather than actually slowing time. Which I admit, I might have missed. =)
Could you recommend any good and interesting literature on this topic? Something for a layman interested in wrapping my head around this? =)
Edit: rereading a lot of this, traveling faster then the speed of light is described as going back in time. It's not. Seeing the past, sure, but that's perception, again.
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and I'm not seeing any evidence.
It's a common tabloid technique.