I often share thoughts like this in the OP's spirit of "pass it on" so that it may benefit someone else.
Take it or leave it. But doubting it, commenting on what it "seems", or downvoting it only makes you look like a fool.
[Sorry for the negative tone, but this is a perfect example of the one thing about hn that really bugs me: people talking when they should be listening.]
If you have generally negligible amounts of anxiety in life, the attitude is probably useless. For those of us that have tons, the judicious usage of this attitude is definitely a lifesaver.
If he is stranger and you don't know him, how did you know that your mentor is wiser then? See, you have already made two mistakes: The first, by not accepting an alternative opinion; and second, by thinking that what you know (or you got from your mentor) is doomed to be the best.
In fact, it does not. Your sample of experience may not be representative. This is complicated by various cognitive biases, including confirmation bias as mentioned downthread.
UPDATE: Let me give an example relating to the original post.
Two people, persons A and B, see a hitchhiker on the side of the road. Person A knows nothing about hitchhikers. Person B has seen several sensational news stories about rapist|murderer hitchhikers. In this case, person A will have to rely on their more general knowledge/opinion of people, and will, in my opinion, be more likely to give the hitchhiker a fair chance.
Doing the right thing is a solid way to run your life.
It lets you sleep better at night and build solid relationships when you're awake.
And, strangely, it does work out in the end. It has for me, every time.
I'm glad it worked out for you, but it's rarely ever "just worked out" for me. So, be happy, because you're very lucky!
And, yes, I am aware that I am very lucky.
That made me smile :) That being said, I agree with your sentiment. And in the end, even if it doesn't work out, you never waste time by doing the right thing. I'd rather end up broke and do "the right thing" than to make money with a business I don't believe is making the world a better place. Moreover it seems doing the right thing is more likely to make you money which is kind of nice :)