He brings up some good points for those who agree with his stance. While they sometimes have a bit of wisdom to impart, I have a tendency to not listen to the jaded and disenfranchised old guard once they begin whining.
When people own their data, and their computing resources, they tend to do whatever they want with it.
Could you imagine waking up one morning to find your computing privileges revoked because you have an overdue parking ticket or some such?
And no, Google is not invulnerable, as evidenced by last year's intrusions that originated from China.