Parent was being too harsh. As a designer, I don't think it looks that bad. It's not amateurish in any serious way, and it avoids the current cliches, which is refreshing to see. To me it kind of looks like cool design from, say, 1997, and I don't mean this as a putdown (I liked 1997) -- the choice of colors and the 3D just give it that sort of feel. Probably not the worst of things; you're targeting "civilians", so your product doesn't need to be too design-forward. Your featured sites look pretty decent.
Seems like a cool product. I'm actually developing something kind of similar, intended mainly for online magazines and long-form blogs.