Shareholders have nothing to complain about, the structure was known when they bought in. If they are not happy, they can sell to people who trust the man more.
Shareholders have nothing to complain about, the structure was known when they bought in. If they are not happy, they can sell to people who trust the man more.
Maybe, but this is a horrible example, since the weighted voting rights things was a well-publicized practice in tech startups for just the purpose FB adopted it well before FB did it, not some clever Zuckerberg innovation based on observation of others’ failures. See, e.g., Google.
In 1985, Jobs apparently owned 15% of the total Apple stock. Wozniak presumably started out with the same share as Jobs, and the early 'garage' team was cut in from his holdings. Markkula became a 1/3 owner as the first investor and third employee, and was likely brought down to 15% as well during the 1980 IPO. The board apparently voted against Jobs unanimously - not to fire him, but to strip him of his management role.
So I definitely don't think it makes sense to claim Zuckerberg 'learned' from this. First, Jobs was never a majority shareholder, simply because there were three founders. Markkula voted against him and Wozniak had already sold many of his shares; this is like Page and Schmidt voting to oust Brin. And beyond that, you're exactly right; Apple went public fast as a consumer-electronics business looking to raise money, while the retained-control 'tech company' model was well-established before Zuckerberg could plausibly have IPOd.
I’m not saying this is particularly innovative, of course. What is remarkable is his ruthlessness to apply it shamelessly and at huge scale.
The problem is that they often have to take additional VC to keep growing and HAVE to give up control or the company dies.
If you need cash to reach escape velocity there's not much you can do
The mistake is compounded by the fact that he thinks that he knows better than those who vote overwhelmingly against him. Facebook needs a new tack, and he is stubbornly maintaining course.
Amazon was a bookstore until it expanded into web services of all things. I remember what an eye opener the success of AWS was too everyone on the outside.
Google was a search/ad company and yet that hasn’t precluded them from trying any sector to see if something sticks. With the move to walled garden apps which exclude Google from indexing them Google’s share price would’ve tanked if not for Android.
Netflix went from shipping DVDs to building a video distribution service and then a studio production arm. Big moves.
My point is these companies aren’t afraid to think outside the box. Facebook can do that. But they don’t. They seem comfortable buying other companies instead. What a Facebook pivot would look like I have no idea. Buying Instagram and WhatsApp were strong moves but Facebook itself isn’t making a lot of bet the farm type moves itself - at least not the way in which the other big tech companies are doing.
The fact that they ceded both to Microsoft boggles the mind.
Facebook looks a lot like Microsoft of the 90s, obsessing over stagnant or slow growing business lines to the exclusion of new opportunities.
Whereas Amazon, Google, and Apple (to some degree) seem to realize it's expand or become irrelevant.
You can build a world-scale business on one great idea, but every idea isn't great. And a lot of successful companies forget they got a lucky roll on their first idea (by definition). Shotgunning and pruning >> all-in.
There's so much potential in FB or was till very recently (Open Compute and React to name two very impressive projects) - I imagine employee retention can only have become harder as the privacy scandals have hit and the share price gains have slowed.
Facebook, as mentioned in parent comments, has essentially tapped out casual social networking as a growth driver.
But casual (e.g. your mom and uncle) is the key there. There are many other kinds of social networking: not as large, but large enough to be worth even Facebook's time.
Developer networking is absolutely a large and valuable demographic. Facebook has demonstrated competency is compiling and making social graphs useful.
Ergo, buying GitHub would allow Facebook to move into a new market while offering new features that GitHub couldn't build on their own.
(Note: I'm charting out an "If Facebook decided not to be stupid and just slap ads on GitHub" business case here)
What does Microsoft of 2019 look like? (Don't take it wrong. I just wonder how people think about these things, or what analogies are in common use.)
Specifically, recognizing that for large, mature businesses, growth has to be driven by new product types that customers are demanding.
And that at that scale nothing starts off "big", but by observing metrics, demand, and properly incubating and then funding launches of internal projects, small popular services can indeed become huge revenue drivers.
The main asset that facebook has is data. I've been reading "21 Lessons for the 21st Century", and I agree with Dr. Harari's argument that we need a regulatory environment for data, and the way that the cultural/political swing is going, all it takes is one election to completely upend the value that facebook holds. I would go one step further and argue that actions that the US has taken in regards to China and Europe endanger facebook in areas where they will most want to be in the coming years.
What will Zuck need to do to survive and thrive in that? I don't know and I have a strong feeling that he doesn't either, but I'm guessing that he has some investors that do.
I'm not aware of any global trackers that avoid dual class shares like this, and I can't very well sell the Facebook bit (I guess I own some somewhere).
I'm from the UK where elections are generally First past the post. In theory I can vote for whoever I want, in practice there are 2 parties who have a chance of winning so half the time I end up voting to keep the other one out. Its a democratic election, but I didn't really have a choice.
That's 2 counter examples to your reasoning.
It's like unfair contract terms. Ideally there would be no such thing, a contract is entered into freely by 2 parties, nothing should be unfair. In practise you need that protection.
Not Facebook's problem at all.
>elections
Not applicable, the choice to not buy a stock is much easier to make than the choice to leave a country because of the voting procedures.
I didn't say it was.
What's the easyness threshold where it becomes applicable?
I'm sure theres a fair few pension holders that would find it very difficult to avoid Facebook.
If you don't know any, you can short it.
Yes my financial exposure would be zero, but I would still be an owner.
I'm also (probably) an owner of facebook, despite having absolutely no say how it is run, as would be traditional as an owner.
Philosophical discussion aside, it isn't just Facebook that does this, so there would quite a few different stocks to track, which kind of undermines the 'stick it in a tracker' idea.