However, even a small state like Rhode Island has plenty of overhead wires, despite being a tenth the size of Denmark.
But surely a rich state like California could dig down wires in areas where it would significant benefits. The benefits are everywhere, obviously, but some areas would gain more benefits than others.
Can a state/country really be considered rich, if it cannot afford to dig down electric wires?
As the saying goes: this suboptimal outcome is a feature, not a bug.
Well, PG+E just went bankrupt, so there aren't any dimes left for shareholders anyway. It's not like they're making a huge margin of profit.
The upshot of this is that every utility in the country would love nothing more than to underground every overhead line in their service area. The reason this doesn’t happen is because public service commissions, who approve capital plans, aren’t willing to saddle customers with the astronomical costs of undergrounding lines (which runs $2-$3M per mile on distribution, depending on rock content of soil).
That might fly in some rich suburb of NYC but try that in Buffalo and the tar and feathers would come out.
So, $4.5 million per customer.
At this point, why be attached to the grid at all?
A renewable setup with storage makes sense at that point.
Building infrastructure well means telling people no. We have a problem with that in the US.
No. You cannot build in the floodplain.
No. You cannot build in the wildland urban interface.
No. You cannot build on a mudslide prone slope.
No. You cannot build in the surge zone.
We just don't do that. Instead we have a system where elect people to give us what we want without paying for the long term consequences. Simply put, we can't fix California, we don't have the money to. People in at risk areas need to be charged for the expense they add to the system, no new customers need added to the system.
If you wonder why the US doesn't build densely, it's because we don't pay for the true cost of our sprawl.
Every time people are forced to make an inefficient decision, the cost is multiplied a thousand fold over time throughout the economy. Money spent burying cables isn’t available to invest elsewhere; a factory goes unbuilt; it doesn’t produce material wealth; it doesn’t hire a young worker into an entry level job; that worker never has a chance to grow and apply their mind to solve new problems; he doesn’t build a new, better factory or tech company one day.
TL;DR Labor rates are above market rates due to the legislative requirements.
See https://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2016/08/31/union-wa... for one point of view on this issue.
It isn't clear to me if these legislative mandates apply to power-line construction though.
https://www.elp.com/articles/powergrid_international/print/v...
http://www.pgecurrents.com/2017/10/31/facts-about-undergroun...
This is part of the trillion dollar sprawl problem we have. We have built a massive amount of infrastructure as cheap as possible, and now we cant afford to built it correctly. People would have never built houses in many places if they had to pay the actual costs.
Something I was reading recently claimed that total operational costs on underground lines also higher in the long run - dielectrics break down, faults are much more expensive etc. Found it counterintuitive, but hard to counter.
The article further talks about people outraged by the amount spent on digging down these cables, as they are generally high voltage cables, and not those that actually reach houses. So I'd imagine regular wires cost less than the above calculation (which includes the 5.7 billion for purchasing the original wires).
[0] In Danish: https://ing.dk/artikel/nyt-opror-stop-milliard-fras-pa-grave...
Edit: A commenter further down noted:
> PG&E has 81,000 miles of distribution lines
So that's 130,357 kilometers. So at the same cost per km as Denmark, 5,312,500 DKK /km, that's 692,521,562,500 DKK or $105,117,847,971.88 USD, ($105.12 billion) USD.
Not considering how many miles of that is actually through mountain ranges and the extra cost of doing highly remote work.
That being said, I do get an impression that more money is lost in bureaucracy/company "fees" in the US than in Denmark.
Because if we catered to every "we're a rich country, why don't we" request across every subject we'd have a government financial situation akin to that of the USSR circa 1988.
Not to mention the fact that burying power lines across rural areas would be exorbitantly expensive. It's one thing to bury power lines in New Jersey. It's another to bury all the power lines in Wisconsin. For what it's worth, the power lines are generally buried in the more dense and rich (must be both, not just one) cites.
Underground lines have their own set of issues, primarily that they have dramatically increased capacitive current. This is manageable, I believe.
Unregulated growth wherever people want to build isn't going to be an affordable problem, no matter how much money people think California has.