Hacker News Reader

The innovation you speak of is either completely superfluous or actively harmful to society. No one needs a Tesla or SpaceX, and society would be much better off without Uber, Airbnb, Amazon, Apple or Facebook. That you consider these companies, all with a notorious track record of badly treating their employees and mishandling their user's data, as good things, speaks volumes about the mindset of some Americans.

View on HN

If what you’re saying was right, these companies wouldn’t have any customers. Clearly society values these companies above zero.

That's a non sequitur. Demand is orthogonal to value. Heroin isn't valuable to society yet it exists.

There is no demand for things that have no value.

The customers of the companies mentioned above obviously see some value in using their services, otherwise they wouldn’t do so.

You seem to be using “is valuable” to mean “is good for”. I’m using it in the economic sense.

I'm not using it in the economic sense because that's not what the conversation is about.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com