The complexity of the chip is higher than the previous models, with three dies under the hood instead of one. The high end chips are closer to Threadripper than they are to the models they're replacing.
I think $750 is still a ridiculously good price, and Intel's feet are being held to the fire.
1950X advantages:
- 4 memory channels vs 2
- 64 PCIe lanes vs 16-4-4
3950X advantages: - 64MB of L3 cache vs 32MB
- DDR4 3200 vs DDR4 2666
- The PCIe lanes are 4.0 vs 3.0
- 3.5Ghz base clock vs 3.4
- 4.7Ghz boost clock vs 4.0
- 15% better instructions per clock
- Full avx2 instead of emulating with two 128-bit units
- 105W vs 180W TDP
The 3950X sounds like quite the improvement! Definitely a great deal IMO.Just a note: Two units for fused multiply-add, otherwise it's four units with two multipliers and two adders.
Ryzen 3000 specs say it can support 128GB of ram but it’s hard to find 32GB DIMMs on the market.
So if you’re trying to build a workstation with lots of ram and more than one GPU, the Ryzen boards are too limited even if you’re willing to buy a nice one.
I feel like if you're requiring 128GB of ram and/or maxing out the PCIE then you're going to have a bigger budget and ThreadRipper makes more sense.
Threadripper 1950x comes with the same core count, more memory channels, more PCI-E lanes and more memory. You can grab one for $499 from amazon.
I wouldn't make the assumption that AMD could sustainably sell that much silicon at that price point.
So you're not going to save more then a few bucks but get a slower and outdated CPU.
Note: I have a TR cooler running on my AM4 board (custom loop though so not completely comparable) and there is more than sufficient space to place it.
In turn, I misunderstood your reply to @lhoff, because in that context, I read it as a rebuttal of the idea that TR parts being expensive by suggesting an AM4 mobo + TR4 cooler as substitutes on a 1950X system.
My 4790K feels so outdated now...
[0] - https://www.amazon.com/AMD-Threadripper-32-thread-Processor-...
The performance comparison will be interesting though. The 3950X should be quite a bit faster than the 1950X when it's not bottlenecked by memory bandwidth, but of course the 1950X still has twice the memory channels. Slightly offset by the Zen2 memory controller supporting higher frequency RAM. So which one is better will depend heavily on workload. I suspect that for a developer workstation the 3950X would be the better performer, most compilation workloads are not very sensitive to bandwidth.
If you don't need those features you're completely correct about the 3950x.
My biggest problem with virtualization is USB. I have a libvirt with GPU passthrough setup that works great, but have been unable to get a USB controller of any sort to passthrough; always winds up in a group with a bunch of other PCI-e devices. And ordinary forwarding with SPICE or something isn’t really sufficient for what I’d like to set up...
(disclaimer - I don't own a board that can do this, I will one day, though).
https://linustechtips.com/main/topic/799836-pcie-lanes-for-r... — nice diagram of lanes
GPUs generally don't come close to saturating x8 3.0 lanes, unless you have a very specific workload (like the new 3dmark bandwidth benchmark AMD used to demo PCIe 4.0).
Games don't do nearly enough asset streaming to use a lot of bandwidth, since the amount of assets used at the same time is limited by VRAM size, and most stuff is kept around for quite some time. Offline 3D renderers like Blender Cycles IIRC just upload the whole scene at once and then path tracing happens in VRAM without much I/O. For buttcoin mining, people literally use boards with tons of x1 slots + risers. No idea how neural nets behave, but would make sense that they also just keep updating the weights in VRAM.
It would leave a fairly big gap in the lineup with nothing to compete against Intel's X299 platform. AM4 is lacking in memory channels and PCIe lanes. Epyc has much lower clockspeeds, much more expensive CPUs, and more expensive motherboards than Threadripper.
As Lisa said, TRs were distinct to Epycs; I guess using UDIMMs vs RDIMMs and much higher base clock (except for the high freq EPYC 7371) led to a few changes.
Well, that is what first-gen Threadripper was. Same socket and all, but with half the connected DDR lanes and a pin telling the motherboard it's not EPYC.
I know it's not a big difference, but given the changes to IO and the 16 core consumer version, I don't see why there would be any internal difference to EPYC this time around (which this article claims will have a variable number of chiplets).
I like small builds that are a good compromise between performance and power needs, and the 3700X looks sweet on 65W at that price point.
If it does, it means the process is struggling to produce chips at that speed, so the headroom is incredibly low and you can forget about overclocking.
That said the part you're missing is binning. The 3800x is definitely the worst binned chiplets, as evidenced by the 3900x and 3950x having the same TDP.
Even then, both AMD and Intel CPUs will pull significantly above their rated TDP when boosting. It's not quite a base-clock measurement (eg 9900K is more like 4.3-4.4 when 95W-limited) but it's definitely not a boost power measurement either.
Again, pretty much just a marketing number these days.
There's a mere 100mhz difference in base clock. Which is what TDP is based off of. No where close to enough of a reduction to fully explain +50% cores at the same TDP
> Again, pretty much just a marketing number these days.
Not really no. You just need to understand it represents all core base frequency thermal design target, and not maximum power draw.
It's still based in reality, though. It's not some random made up number.
And binning is an extremely real thing with very significant impact. Not sure why you seem to be trying to outright dismiss it.
That was a 34% decrease in cost for comparable models after 1 generation. If that trend follows then the comparible Zen2+/Zen3 model will only be around $500. So, hopefully you just need to wait a year.
That's not going to happen this time around. Intel doesn't really have a response to 16C consumer processors. Best thing they can do is release the 10C chip they're working on... probably at $500 again. And they will be behind the 12C version that AMD has at $500 already.
The only similarly aggressive move that Intel could even make would be to drop 10C to the $350 segment (perhaps with Hyperthreading disabled), which would be a massive blow to their margins.