Citizens on Patrol: What If Your Neighbor Could Give You a Parking Ticket?
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
On the other hand, as services like Nextdoor illustrate, many neighbors have an inherent fear and discrimination against their minority neighbors, and can show the same type of overreacting behavior as the police.. I guess I'd rather have enforcement from individuals without license to kill.
I'm confused by this phrase. do you think that minor infractions shouldn't be enforced at all? is it "harassment" anytime someone faces a consequence for violating the law?
For example, if my office had a policy that everybody should wipe down the microwave after using it, it wouldn't be a problem if that rule was enforced across the board.
But if there was someone in the office who hid behind a potted plant and watched specifically for me to microwave my food so they could catch me in the act, and if I noticed that they seemed to only care about my food and no one else's, and if I noticed that even when other office members did the same thing next to me that I was still the only person who got in trouble -- at a certain point it would be reasonable for me to assume that this was personal, and not just about the microwave.
Eric Garner was accused of selling illegal cigarettes, was this a crime? Yes. Should he been put in a choke hold and held down by multiple officers despite being clearly subdued and repeatedly saying that he could not breathe? No. Sandra Bland was killed over a parking ticket. Recently, in Phoenix, a young family was threaten horribly because the daughter "shoplifted" a doll without the parents knowledge.
There is a clear pattern of disproportionate force used in relation to the actual activity being prosecuted.
Minor infractions should definitely (always) be enforced, but an argument could be made that they're unequally enforced currently, which might be interpreted/manifest as harassment against some.
> It sounds like you need to do some reading
you are no in no position to recommend me reading when you evade the most basic questions about the central premise of your argument.
Speaking from personal experience, while it's private property and legally allowed, and despite the HOA having good intentions in theory, this leads to an attitude of distrust amongst neighbors, people weaponizing petty complaints or viewing their neighbors as "informers", and/or a cabal being vocal, passive-aggressive complainers about everything.
A better solution would be farming this out to a private unaffiliated company -- although by no means perfect, would prevent the detrimental effects on quality of community.
These types see themselves as defenders of law and order, protectors of good, and take pride in that not a single infraction on any day anywhere goes without a citation. They know all, and see all, and disapprove of all.
And the HOA management association loves them because they bring in tens of thousands of additional revenue per month, and even enables them to confiscate a few houses now and then should the homeowner contest the charges and refuse.
I would never ever ever ever live in an HOA controlled area again.
I think one of the key ideas was "checks and balances"
Take a 4 hour class, and you can write tickets for cars parked illegally in handicap spots.
If so, why?
Just the easiest thing to spot and not misdiagnose, I guess?
- non-EV cars in EV charging spots
- EVs not hooked up to charge in EV charging spots
"Charging spots are for charging" seems very reasonable.
Couple that with gpm's sibling comment and I think it's too ripe for abuse. (I hate getting ICEd out of a charging spot as much as anyone, but I'm not sure that the benefits outweigh the drawbacks here.)
For instance, if it's two people at the same power level, it gets complicated. If it's someone at a high power level defending someone at a lower power level, it's ok.
So defending handicapped people, or kids, or puppies is ok.
I've heard stories of people breaking a car window to get a kid or puppy out, and that's pretty much universally accepted.
But defending other people at the same level as yourself might be a harder sell.
I remember reading that the difference between police and citizens is that police can give out misdemeanor tickets.
I think teslas have the ability to lock the cable in the charging port.
There's an aftermarket $60 for $1 worth of plastic lock system: https://evannex.com/products/capturepro-charging-lock-for-te...
Of course I realize that this could easily be abused, and you'd instantly get a lot of irate drivers calling for volunteers giving tickets to cyclists who blow through red lights, and it's tricky where exactly you'd want to draw a line there on citizen enforcement.
It seems like a sociologically simpler option may be soon within reach, though: once we have fully self-driving cars, you could commission a few parking enforcement bots that would tirelessly hand out tickets, in a more or less unbiased manner, all day and night long!
You don't have to stop the violator, because they're usually not present, and you can leave the ticket on the vehicle.
The circumstances that lead to a finding of violation are subject to less dispute. Cyclist claims light was green, citizen enforcer claims light was red, is harder to prove vs parker says time was 5:30 and citizen enforcer says time was 4:30. Some parking tickets are more sensitive to location -- if the vehicle is very near the boundary between acceptable and not acceptable, perhaps an escalation to a sworn officer is in order, but parking in a red zone / parking in a bike lane / parking in disabled without a visible permit is usually clear cut.
These problems exist to some extent with professionals too, but it's easier to work on the trust angle with a small pool of salaried people that presumably want to keep their jobs for a long time, as opposed to a large pool of random citizens for whom this is a side gig or volunteer effort.
It’s just chaos. Local police are underfunded so they are understaffed and are too busy to enforce code or parking violations. And nobody pays their parking tickets anymore anyway. You have to rack up 20+ before they will put a boot on your car.
https://www.ksla.com/story/7065953/shreveport-council-approv...
Not saying it's a good thing, but I feel like it's inevitable with the ubiquity of cameras.
Just imagine how effective boycotts will be. You just look at the grocery store shelf, and you automagically see which foods you can buy. They'll be able to give tickets on cars much easier as well. Just have AI's pour over everyone's monday video after hours, and get that ticket for parking in the handicapped spot in your mail on wednesday.
Most of the impact will be far more intimate though. Bartenders' glasses will just say: "Do Not Serve" when they look at a person. (Automatically keeping track of how many drinks each person is getting.) Women and men at bars will be able to just look at each other, and it will say "Sex Assault Risk", "Has Kids" or "Violent Crime Conviction" or whatever.
And that's just connecting the glasses to the public databases. They would also be connected to the small private data repositories updated by a person's close friend group. Imagine the information overlays there. Everything from "Has Girlfriend", to "STD Reported", to "Puts Out", to "Small Penis".
I can imagine life becoming almost an open book in the far future.
Lol, I think your age might be showing? Surely you get the charge auto-deducted from your account.
That way you can get auto-fined by the bank for having insufficient 'ShelbyvilleCryptoCoin' to pay. Then get auto-fined for getting an unauthorised over-draft, then auto-charged by the government for financial irregularity, then auto-fired by work for "bringing disrepute on the company". Then your 'worker car privelege' gets rescinded and you get picked up by a robocop, citizen, before you even finish your commute.
First your wife knows is an automated message saying she no longer owns the house as it's been sold to fund your trip to a prison colony on Rigel Prime ...
Or, maybe I watched too much dystopian sci-fi.
I thought I was using as much imagination as possible coming up with just my likely scenarios. Yours are more Sci-Fi, but there is an uneasy feeling that maybe some of these "auto reporting" type things could actually happen. Likely not to the extent you indicate in your post, but I wonder if they may in the future just auto deduct tickets and such from your bank accounts?
I also like the fact that in this future we send prisoners to different solar systems, but still haven't sorted out self driving cars. Have you not heard Musk? We're getting full self driving next year!
Also, there might be dangerous places you don't want to risk damaging a nice robot in!
Its like universities and prisons. Both have cheap labour available, but the phd students both want to be there, and are paying to be there, thus universities are more profitable than prisons.
I wish we could report video to the police for dangerous driving... The police waste money enforcing rules that are only loosely correlated with preventing danger. Why not use the strongest signal possible - actual dangerous driving or near misses etc.
To avoid the "granny reporting everything" problem and avoid the "anti-social" problem, only allow three submissions per year?
Fundamentally, people should be put in a cooperative environment; having a significant part of the population be in "cop mode", looking for offenses, would be very harmful for society.
yes. but, a case can be made that someone who parks in a spot reserved for people with disabilities, or parks their car in the middle of a bike lane is disrupting and damaging the cooperative environment. furthermore, in the US the presence of guns and people willing to use guns means that confronting such a person directly is significantly riskier than it would be in some other, truly civilized, country.
Police would, at least, have more training though. So there's that.
Again, police are people. Sure they're supposed to follow the rules. But sometimes they don't.
What makes police better is that they at least have the training. So they have the knowledge of how to do it right. Whether or not they do it right in fact is an entirely separate issue.
>To prevent crime and disorder, as an alternative to their repression by military force and severity of legal punishment.
>To recognise always that the power of the police to fulfil their functions and duties is dependent on public approval of their existence, actions and behaviour, and on their ability to secure and maintain public respect.
>To recognise always that to secure and maintain the respect and approval of the public means also the securing of the willing co-operation of the public in the task of securing observance of laws.
>To recognise always that the extent to which the co-operation of the public can be secured diminishes proportionately the necessity of the use of physical force and compulsion for achieving police objectives.
>To seek and preserve public favour, not by pandering to public opinion, but by constantly demonstrating absolutely impartial service to law, in complete independence of policy, and without regard to the justice or injustice of the substance of individual laws, by ready offering of individual service and friendship to all members of the public without regard to their wealth or social standing, by ready exercise of courtesy and friendly good humour, and by ready offering of individual sacrifice in protecting and preserving life.
>To use physical force only when the exercise of persuasion, advice and warning is found to be insufficient to obtain public co-operation to an extent necessary to secure observance of law or to restore order, and to use only the minimum degree of physical force which is necessary on any particular occasion for achieving a police objective.
>To maintain at all times a relationship with the public that gives reality to the historic tradition that the police are the public and that the public are the police, the police being only members of the public who are paid to give full-time attention to duties which are incumbent on every citizen in the interests of community welfare and existence.
>To recognise always the need for strict adherence to police-executive functions, and to refrain from even seeming to usurp the powers of the judiciary, of avenging individuals or the State, and of authoritatively judging guilt and punishing the guilty.
>To recognise always that the test of police efficiency is the absence of crime and disorder, and not the visible evidence of police action in dealing with them.