Ceteris paribus - everything else left unchanged - yes, it might make sense to build more nuclear. But what we really need is to build more renewables and to simultaneously scale down our energy use. To put it bluntly our energy using industry has to take a small hit.
This is one of the things even I as a leftist say the market can solve nicely. Electricity can get more expensive at night or when the wind doesn't blow. If it becomes uneconomical to do a certain business, then we should stop doing it, or only do it at certain times.
To put it differently, industry works like a buffered solution in chemistry. Put in more acid, and the buffering prevents the PH value from dropping. Shut down power plants, and the market will largely absorb the effect. Things will become marginally more expensive, or production will move to other regions where it makes more sense, but we will not have blackouts like some people fear.
This is why the Green parties in a lot of countries need to be politically opposed. They attract people who care less about the environment than about changing our way of life.
Case in point: in Antwerp they're about to spend a cool billion to put a roof on the ring road, to put some plant pots and bicycle paths there.
Conservatives disagree that today's profit is inconsistent with a livable tomorrow.
You can attribute whatever motivations you like to conservatives, but if you claim they don't want a bright future you are wrong. Just because you don't agree with them doesn't mean they are evil or stupid. At absolute worst they have different priorities for what they think a bright future looks like. They are just as good at planning ahead as progressives, and stereotypically more organised albeit less passionate about achieving their goals.
The conservative bright future seems to be "My family will have enough money to buy safety and comfort in whatever dystopia global warming creates".
If you'd like to know the realistic reason, it's because of past experience. This [1] was published back in 1989. "The most conservative scientific estimate that the Earth’s temperature will rise 1 to 7 degrees in the next 30 years, said [director of UN Environmental Program] Brown." 30 years from the date of that article's publication is 6 days from now. Temperatures have increased 0.52 [2] degrees since then. He may have meant fahrenheit since he was the director in New York and so was likely speaking with an American demographic in mind. But even then that's still only about 0.9 degrees - still under his "most conservative scientific estimate." The article was full of plenty of other alarming hyperbole which also turned out to be completely false.
The problem is that that article is not an outlier. We've now had several decades of alarming climate predictions. The reason this timing is relevant is because we've now reached the point to where we go back to these predictions and see how they have played out. And in general the quality of predictions has been quite poor. Of course the response here is that 'well climate science is hard, and they're at least getting the general trend right - up.' The problem with this is that this general trend goes back long before even the industrial revolution. And so predicting heating to continue is about as meaningful as me predicting that in 30 years the stock market will be higher than it is today, which it almost certainly will be. What really matters are the specifics.
So this drives people into two groups. People that think that the mistakes of times past are something we've overcome and the predictions of today are now meaningful. The other group tend to think that the past 30 years of predictions will be representative of the next 30 years of predictions. People can view similar data and come to radically different conclusions. And only to preempt the typical mass-level ad-hominem that generally mentions here I'd mention individuals such as Richard Linzen [3]: MIT atmospheric physicist, member of the National Academies of Sciences, Fellow of American Geophysical Union, fellow of American Meteorological Society, lead author on the IPCC's 2001 climate report, etc. He also falls into the latter group. I would emphasize that this is not an appeal to authority (which I think is generally a very foolish idea), but rather a preempting of the exact same.
[1] - https://apnews.com/bd45c372caf118ec99964ea547880cd0
[2] - https://climate.nasa.gov/vital-signs/global-temperature/
The models we have are wrong. There is no doubt about it. But there is very little evidence that they're wrong in the direction where we can just do business as usual and still live a comfortable live in fifty years.
ALL the people with significant power are wealthy.
I'm not downplaying the importance of the poor voting in elections, but that happens twice a year (primaries and general election) and the choice the poor get is which wealthy person gets the power, or in rarer cases, which policy proposed by wealthy people is enacted. The rest of the year, the wealthy people make all the decisions. Certainly which wealthy person is in power makes a difference, but they're still all wealthy people.
And to be clear, no major party is immune to this. Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren, Ron Paul--no supposed heroes of change are poor or even middle class.
> So this drives people into two groups. People that think that the mistakes of times past are something we've overcome and the predictions of today are now meaningful. The other group tend to think that the past 30 years of predictions will be representative of the next 30 years of predictions.
I'm not in either group. I don't believe we've overcome the mistakes of the past. I don't believe we even know what all of those mistakes are, so we can't possibly have overcome them all. What I do believe is that the only effective mechanism we have of predicting the future is science, and that science is a slow process that often gets things wrong, but slowly gets less wrong as it progresses. An alternate theory which just decides to let markets decide the truth isn't even wrong--it's a stopped clock, which is sometimes right but never useful. Science hasn't been right and it may continue to be wrong, but at least it's trying to find the truth via a proven method. Letting markets decide isn't even trying to find the truth.
On the predictions issue, I fully agree with you. And I find it disappointing that debates on this topic in general tend to avoid this actual core issue - should we trust the current predictions, or not? And like you mention there are varying degrees there. So the real question is should society's trust of climatologists' trust of themselves be high enough to justify large scale change, or not? Instead debates are people just straw manning one another to no end, which results in both sides thinking the other is full of idiots. No progress is made, divisions are deepened, and further amicable discussion becomes ever more unlikely, all this in turn means any sort of lasting change becomes ever less likely.
That's fair--I think all I'd like to agree on here is that it's not useful to pretend that parties aren't majority wealthy when you weight for actual power rather than simply counting people.
One subtlety in my initial statement that I didn't really explain was that it's not necessary to be wealthy in order to believe that your family will be wealthy in the future.
> Romney was pro-choice, until he wanted to be president. Biden was against federal funding for abortions, until he wanted to be president. It's unlikely their personal views ever changed, but a politician's job is to get elected - and so what a politician says or advocates and what a politician believes don't necessarily have all that much in common.
This points to another issue, which is that "liberal" and "conservative" are really problematic groupings of ideas. Abortion has nothing to do with climate change, but it's usually impossible to vote on one without taking a stance on the other.
> On the predictions issue, I fully agree with you. And I find it disappointing that debates on this topic in general tend to avoid this actual core issue - should we trust the current predictions, or not? And like you mention there are varying degrees there. So the real question is should society's trust of climatologists' trust of themselves be high enough to justify large scale change, or not?
I don't know if I would say I "trust" climatologists, but I believe that they are presenting the best information we have, and I believe that we should always operate on the best information we have, rather than simply doing what's profitable.
> Instead debates are people just straw manning one another to no end, which results in both sides thinking the other is full of idiots. No progress is made, divisions are deepened, and further amicable discussion becomes ever more unlikely, all this in turn means any sort of lasting change becomes ever less likely.
To be clear, I don't think that (most) conservatives are stupid or malicious, and I think that too often liberals have done liberal ideologies a great disservice by making that assumption.
The steam generators, turbine, electric generators, condenser and cooling systems are all more or less the same as they would be in an equivalent coal plant. While I'm sure these things have significant lead times they are essentially off the shelf parts.
The secondary containment structure doesn't seem any harder to build than say a suspension bridge.
The only real challenge the seems to be the primary containment structure and potentially other elements of the primary heating loop. I heard it mentioned that possibly only Japan had the ability to make these at the moment.
But you don't need anything particularly difficult to build for construction to take forever. Look at Stutgart 21, or Berlin's airport.
The red tape.
https://www.technologyreview.com/s/612564/chinas-losing-its-...
Edit: Why the downvotes without a counterpoint?
And I'm actually pronuclear.
Personally, I'm on board with getting rid of nuclear and fossil energy sources both, which appears technologically feasible to me (offshore windparks help with base load, flywheels can get you through the day and power-2-gas through the winter).
https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-d...
Yes, Chernobyl happened, but even the worst nuclear accident in the history of mankind is 200 people. Fukushima was 2 or 3? The Banqiao dam was over a hundred THOUSAND dead.
[1] https://news.nationalgeographic.com/2015/10/151008-chernobyl...
[2] https://www.theatlantic.com/photo/2017/03/the-wild-boars-of-...
The direct cause is that there are no people around, not that a nuclear disaster happened. The nuclear disaster caused the people to leave, which makes the disaster the indirect cause of nature thriving.
It’s not as though the increase in background radiation made nature thrive. The lack of people did that.
I’m all in favor of nature reserves, but we do not need nuclear disasters to create them and I don’t think we should let luck pick around which nuclear plant we want a nature reserve. We should put our nature reserves wherever we damn well please.
(I’m honestly questioning whether you actually read the article you linked. I will admit, I also didn’t before I wrote the comment. I was surprised to find that it makes essentially the same argument I’m using, down to using the same exact words.)
1) increase of background radiation is not harmful to "nature" (usually defined as "all living things, arbitrarily excluding humans"), or at least less harmful than human presence
2) nuclear plants, merely by existing, tend to limit surrounding human population, and in case of accident totally eliminate it
3) the presence of humans is worse for nature than literally the worst nuclear plant accident ever
The original argument I was arguing against is "nuclear plants are bad because they're bad for the environment". However all evidence points to nuclear plants being good for the environment. You can't build nature reserves "wherever you damn please" because most habitable areas are already populated by humans. We can however build more nuclear plants, which has a two-pronged effect of reducing carbon emissions and limiting population around them, naturally creating nature hotspots.
How can you suggest that there's no hand-washing going on with coal emissions and keep a straight face?
https://science.sciencemag.org/content/sci/353/6299/547/F2.l...
(Data is only up to 2015.) Source: https://science.sciencemag.org/content/353/6299/547
"how much" / (10 years) = "how fast"
Why don't we build the generators that can be built in a reasonable time frame, where there's the actual political will to build them. If and when there is political will for nuclear, we can see where we are, because I would guess by that point wind and solar turn out to be good enough anyway.