For me a "good tool" is robust, reliable, and easy to fix. For most of the data scientists I know, a "good tool" is one where "a single easy to remember command magically does the thing I want in one go".
And I get it, that last part is super appealing, especially for people who care more about answers to their problem than in technology, I don't blame people for wanting that.
But my personal experience is that many of these magical single command tools break a lot when you try to use them in any non-standard environment (for example, something that is not Ubuntu and where you don't have sudo to fix/install system packages) and I work in environments like that a lot. So the fact that e.g. cabal-install requires a bit more explicit work to setup initially is outweighed by the fact that I can reliably install it on any *nix system where I have a login and sufficient diskspace and have it Just Work.