Unless you (Gruber) care prominently about Apple/Google and other places with enough inbound link equity that your marginal SEO increase is minuscule and marginal UX*appreciation gain is large.
But for everyone else, there's MasterCard.
So how far will you go to screw up your users' experience? Where's the limit?
Forgive me if my sarcasm detector is broken here, but...really? It's a page title. It's not a harbinger of horrible UX.
I think it's a fair question--once you trade even the smallest marginal piece of UX for a marginal piece of SEO ranking, you start down a slope. It may or may not be a slippery slope, but it's certainly not a level plane.